lb3 said:
12th Man said:
I can't quite see it your way, but I understand it.
In hindsight, I think the best move would've been to be in Ukraine in force before the invasion could've started. I don't think the Russians would've invaded had there been 5000 or so American military there embedded with the Ukrainians. If these sanctions outrage the Russians instead of deterring them, we may end up with far more people in harms way than what we could've gotten away with in January. This is just a guess, though.
Nobody knows, and I hope you're right.
Stationing our troops in the west wouldn't have prevented the Russians from entering Donbas and if we stationed troops in the east, Russia would have just sent his little green men to turn up the heat on the existing civil war.
Trump threatened Moscow if Putin entered Ukraine. Those credible threats would have prevented things from ever starting. Instead our president talked about varied economic responses if there was a minor excursion.
This administration failed in both preparation and response. I'm not talking about the Donbas and/or Crimea- I'm talking status quo ante bellum.
I DO think positioning appreciable numbers of Americans in unoccupied Ukraine would've given pause to Russian planners -especially had we deployed aviation and anti-air assets. Now, you could dress Putin in a leather teddy and he'd still have more balls than Lyndon Johnson ever did, but I'm not talking about the relatively small number of Soviet/Chinese advisors that deterred LBJ from un-muzzling our Naval & Air Force action over North Vietnam; I mean 5k combat troops embedded to "train up the Ukrainians". My $.02 is that that would've been an effective deterrent.
It also would've been a far more lucrative plan to NOT green-light the damned Russians as Anvil Joe did when he stammered out that we would not go in to protect Ukraine. Stoopid.
All this discussion is better reserved for the post mortem hot wash, and I apologize for the derail. Aw hell, maybe we're just giving hope that there will still be something for us to all talk about in the Ukraine/Russia off-season