Sapper Redux said:
The Banned said:
Out of curiosity, what is your biggest objection to there being a God?
If you mean any deity, period, my reading of history over the years, my admittedly limited knowledge of cosmology and my better knowledge of biology suggest either no god active in our universe or one so vastly different and removed from us that it doesn't make much practical difference. Admittedly, I could be wrong about that. I'm much less decisive about the existence of something we would call a god than I am that the human conceptions we currently have of God or gods does not exist. The Christian concept of a trinity and a God that is omnipotent, omnipresent, and omnibenevolent simply don't hold up for me under scrutiny. I've reached this conclusion academically, through logical reasoning, and through my own experience with the problem of suffering and evil. And please don't sit here and assume I just haven't heard the right apologetics. I've read just about every reasonably modern (and plenty of ancient) figures you could name. From the more popular writers like Strobel to the inbetween like Craig to more academic writers like Swinburne.
ETA: after re-reading your post, I think you mean that the answers to my questions really don't matter because whatever the source of consciousness is doesn't care about us like the Christian conception of God does?
You've always come across as well researched so that doesn't surprise me. How do you deal with consciousness arising from the unconscious? In order for matter to exist, there must be a material world. In order for space to exist, there must be a "space" for space. It seems to me that in order for consciousness to exist, we must live in a universe that is conscious (or created by a conscious being). How does the part (humans) have an ability that the whole (the universe/God) does not?
Sorry if that comes across as rambling but I have long thought of this issue but never asked the question.
As for the Omni's: is that an issue of all 3 together not making sense? Are one or two of those Omni's possible?