dermdoc said:
Couple of things. John Piper is a five point Calvinist so I assume he believes in double predestination. By that theology, his son Abraham is either predestined to be elect or not. So it is up to God, not Piper, what the eternal destiny of Abraham is. And if we get rid of every Christian leader with rebellious kids, we are going to lose a lot of preachers, deacons, etc.
Secondly, I do not think that I have the ability to know who is "going to hell" or not. That is not my call and I believe is based on the decision of every individual whether they accept or reject God. I do not know their heart.
Thirdly, you sure seem to like to judge other people a lot.
Fourthly, I believe Scripture is pretty clear everyone is resurrected.
1) So?! You disregard the immutable Word of God on eldership requirements because the current crop of elders are sooo bad that they cant maintain the requisites, ergo we must keep them? That's about as bassackwards as you can get.
2) And that's because you have no ecclesiastical authority. Man, those who were not Christ himself, --sinful men-- absolutely declared anathema on individuals who distorted the Gospel. Read Galatians, its sitting right there for you. In fact for 2000 years the church has been excommunicating individuals who refuse to comport to the standards of orthodoxy, read 2 Thessalonians 3, its right there for you. The apostle Paul delegates the ability and authority to judge congregants on their inclusion in the body of Christ.
"you dont know their hearts." Look, Thessalonica is *chef's kiss.* If you read Acts you see how the church at Thessalonica was founded. Paul was only in the city for a short time, the Jews started a mob and Paul had to flee, the converts were fined and beaten. Paul writes the first letter. Then he hears back, then he writes the second letter. The context of 2 Thess 3 is that there were those who confessed Christ with their lips, they may have even endured the persecution from the world in Christ's name, they even had the best attendance (they were waiting for the 2nd coming, day and night). But Paul judged them as idle and despite "what they had in their hearts" and despite "what they professed" Paul STILL judged them for excommunication--if they refused to act in the ways he had given the church.
3) Im sorry I follow the instructions of the Lord. There are no crowns in heaven for being naive. Do you really want me to give you the dozens of imperatives for the church to judge and discern and to be shrewd? No. You wouldnt want that because it would go to war with the idol you old in your heart: Harmonia. She is your god. "My gift is mercy" No, bud that's not a gift described by the Scripture (Isaiah 11, 1 Cor 12). Its a cop-out. It allows you to refuse to be principled. You can peddle some milquetoast religious convictions and say "how can you judge the human heart?!" Thats simple, "the heart, above all else, is deceitful and desperately wicked." You're right, it is foolish to judge hearts, rather the Lord instructs us to judge actions and words. Those are the wellsprings of the heart.
4) Yes the unbeliever will get stand before God's judgement.
But they are not in Christ, visavis Col 1:15-23 whereas Christ is firstborn of the resurrection and the reconciliation
for believers. In fact, that passage details that one must endure in the faith to receive such inheritance.