Entertainment
Sponsored by

Nirvana vs Pearl Jam vs Smashing Pumpkins

11,215 Views | 77 Replies | Last: 9 yr ago by TyHolden
Macarthur
How long do you want to ignore this user?
PJ was the better band.

Nirvana prob had the more influence

SP is third, imo, but I wouldn't even categorize them with grunge.


As others have mentioned, soundgarden was actually the best band of that era. AIC was also tragically overlooked.
PatriotAg02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Apparently the original Pumpkins lineup is reuniting for a tour.....Billy, James, D'arcy, and Jimmy.

Never got to see them live. So you're saying there's a chance.....
$3 Sack of Groceries
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The Pumpkins are at the very bottom of the list simply because Corgan sounds like a GD injured howler monkey. I hated them then and they held up even worse.

I think PJ held up the best.
HummingbirdSaltalamacchia
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Pearl Jam for me. Ten was one of the first albums that I bought on my own. Enjoy Nirvana and SP from time to time, but PJ still has more listenability to me, then and now.
Mort Rainey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Trident 88 said:

None of these bands were truly great.


jokershady
How long do you want to ignore this user?
91_Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I never undertstood the appeal of smashing pumpkins. I would never to.choose to listen to one of their songs.

I never liked Nirvana but I can understand why the masses liked them.

Pearl Jam actually had some good songs though, but I think their fan base is off-kilter and takes them and themselves way too seriously.

So I would pick pearl Jam.
suprafly03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I like looking at these responses and seeing what year the responder graduated...

Being class of '03 I kinda feel like I can't appropriately judge Nirvana. Fighters of the Foo were more inline with my age group...

For me it'd be

The Pumpkins
Pearl Jam
Nirvana

But Foo Fighters are above all...
Ag03 CQE
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Nirvana - the only real grunge band of the three options

Pearl Jam - great music, but it's difficult to enjoy being preached at about social inequalities and politics by a gas station attendant

Smashing Pumpkins - some good music, some generic music, Billy Corgan's voice
AggieChemist
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GnR
Skid Row
Ugly Kid Joe
Poison
Bon Jovi

F all your grunge and your ****ty musical menstrual cramping.
NoahAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This whole thread is completely subjective, so everyone is right, and everyone is wrong.

To me, Nirvana = Barry Sanders; i.e., reached a higher peak of greatness. Pearl Jam = Emmitt Smith; clearly longer career, and larger library of music, but didn't reach the level of awesomeness that Nirvana did. I dig Nirvana more now in my mid-30s than I did as a punk kid in the 90s.

I never appreciated the greatness of Alice In Chains until fairly recently, long after Layne's death.

Still love Foo Fighters and Soundgarden.
Bruce Almighty
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AggieChemist said:

GnR
Skid Row
Ugly Kid Joe
Poison
Bon Jovi

F all your grunge and your ****ty musical menstrual cramping.
Thank God for grunge. We may have been subjected to more Damn Yankees albums.
Gigem314
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What I appreciate the most from the 'grunge' era was the stripped down 'back to basics' nature of the music and where it steered mainstream music as a whole.

Not a bunch of effects and "new fad" digital sounds. Not a bunch of hair, make-up, and ridiculous costumes. It was guitars, drums, bass, and vocals...what a concept. The recordings actually sounded like something you'd hear live.

It was the counter-culture to the 80's...which had become all about the image and technology, and not the music itself.

So while I wasn't always crazy about every big grunge band, I respect how that era swung the pendulum.

Heck, I remember reading about how Nirvana and Pearl Jam thought their debut albums were "over-produced". Pearl Jam actually re-released Ten not long ago, and they took out all the hazy reverb and turned the guitars up...it sounds amazing compared to the original (which was still good obviously).

I feel like we're in the middle of another "80's-like" era right now...with a lot of carbon copied music across most genre's that's more about the image/tech than the songs and music. I wonder if something will come along at some point that swings it back the other way again.
Definitely Not A Cop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
You are already kind of seeing that begin in Country music, I hope at least.
Noblemen06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

I wonder if something will come along at some point that swings it back the other way again.
One can only hope.
BarryProfit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
astros4545 said:

Alice In Chains


This is the correct answer.

PS Smashing Pumpkins aren't in the same league of the others.
PatriotAg02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BarryProfit said:

astros4545 said:

Alice In Chains


This is the correct answer.

PS Smashing Pumpkins aren't in the same league of the others.


Opinion.....they're my favorite of that era.
MookieBlaylock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Only 1 band is still making music

It's not even close as to which band is the best

62strat
How long do you want to ignore this user?
suprafly03 said:

I like looking at these responses and seeing what year the responder graduated...

Being class of '03 I kinda feel like I can't appropriately judge Nirvana. Fighters of the Foo were more inline with my age group...

For me it'd be

The Pumpkins
Pearl Jam
Nirvana

But Foo Fighters are above all...


Dude I'm class of 02 and I was obsessed with grunge when it came out. You were plenty old enough to get into it.
62strat
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MookieBlaylock said:

Only 1 band is still making music

It's not even close as to which band is the best


they weren't in the ops question but we still have aic and soundgarden making music.
superunknown
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AggieChemist said:

Skid Row
Ugly Kid Joe
Poison
Bon Jovi


Teacher_Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Really can't fathom anyone ever putting PJ above the Pumpkins. Y'all crazy.
Bruce Almighty
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Pearl Jam > Smashing Pumpkins
Teacher_Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Man, there's nothing I dislike more than someone whose opinion of music doesn't align with mine. You have stated that you enjoy listening to a band more than a band that I enjoy listening to the most. Consider me offended.
Orbit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1. Pumpkins
2. AIC
3. STP
4. PJ
5. Nirvana
6. Soundgarden

Love them all, though.
thriller03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I have personally always enjoyed the Pumpkins more than PJ or Nirvana, but I don't think the merits of PJ/Nirvana and their influence over that genre can be disputed. PJ's longevity is impressive.

I will say this...while each band had their own sound, I think the Pumpkins - when they were on - were the best at manufacturing their sound. I dig Nirvana and PJ both, but I still crank songs like "Muzzle", "Rocket", and "Hummer" up more than most. I feel like that era of Pumpkins material was Corgan turning the sound in his head into something real at its finest.
themessenger
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm very biased but Pearl Jam is the best of that group. I've seen them close to 20 times though and have been a massive fan since the beginning.

I loved SP and consider Siamese Dream one of my favorite albums ever, but I couldn't get into them post Mellon Collie. Their first three albums are great, and their B Side album has some great tracks also.

Nirvana is the most influential though I think and while I don't really listen to them much anymore, they had some great songs. That MTV Unplugged album is the best of the Unplugged series I believe, which is saying a lot considering the AIC one is amazing as well.

So for my tastes PJ > Old SP > Nirvana
Bruce Almighty
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teacher_Ag said:

Man, there's nothing I dislike more than someone whose opinion of music doesn't align with mine. You have stated that you enjoy listening to a band more than a band that I enjoy listening to the most. Consider me offended.
crybaby
VanZandt92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
themessenger said:

I'm very biased but Pearl Jam is the best of that group. I've seen them close to 20 times though and have been a massive fan since the beginning.

I loved SP and consider Siamese Dream one of my favorite albums ever, but I couldn't get into them post Mellon Collie. Their first three albums are great, and their B Side album has some great tracks also.

Nirvana is the most influential though I think and while I don't really listen to them much anymore, they had some great songs. That MTV Unplugged album is the best of the Unplugged series I believe, which is saying a lot considering the AIC one is amazing as well.

So for my tastes PJ > Old SP > Nirvana
MW03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1. Smashing Pumpkins
2. Pearl Jam
3. Nirvana
62strat
How long do you want to ignore this user?
thriller03 said:

I have personally always enjoyed the Pumpkins more than PJ or Nirvana, but I don't think the merits of PJ/Nirvana and their influence over that genre can be disputed. PJ's longevity is impressive.

I will say this...while each band had their own sound, I think the Pumpkins - when they were on - were the best at manufacturing their sound. I dig Nirvana and PJ both, but I still crank songs like "Muzzle", "Rocket", and "Hummer" up more than most. I feel like that era of Pumpkins material was Corgan turning the sound in his head into something real at its finest.
Billy was way more of an overproducer of their songs. All the others were very bare bones.. single guitar tracks, very minimal over dubbing, etc.

I read somewhere that a few SP songs have like a dozen overdubbed guitar tracks.

This is a big difference between SP and the others. Look at tonight tonight or disarm vs. 'ballads' like elderly woman/daughter or rooster/no excuses.. way more production on SP.
Definitely Not A Cop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ag 11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Nirvana might be the most overrated band of all time
Teacher_Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bruce, I was being heavily sarcastic.
Bruce Almighty
How long do you want to ignore this user?
so was I
Page 2 of 3
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.