BenFiasco14 said:
Sucks not having room service or house keeping. If there's an issue, there isn't an on location staff to come fix it. Stuff like that. Plus I think the hotels have become a lot more aggressive in marketing their reward programs. You don't have to be traveling constantly for work to start getting rewards. The short term rentals don't have anything like that and understandably so.
Yeah, for me it's really more about cost-effectiveness. Points and rewards definitely help with that. For just the wife and myself, it's typically a hotel. It helps that I have lifetime status from significant work travel and always been a heavy points earner due to that travel. That status includes free breakfast for both of us every morning of the stay at a minimum, and often includes free room upgrades and access to the club lounge if they have one on site.
If we're meeting up with other couples or an extended family vacation, it's typically Airbnb/vrbo. No complaints from me and the only truly bad experience I ever had was in Hong Kong in 2015, but that was partially our fault.
Or in a place like Hawaii, I want the resort experience, and I don't care as much about price.