Story Poster
Photo by John Glaser/USA Today Sports
Texas A&M Football

Around CFB: Critics minimizing A&M's potential aren't paying attention

November 27, 2017
45,596

A prevailing opinion among national sports media lately is that Texas A&M lacks self-awareness. The narrative is that A&M has no business seeking a high-profile football coach like Florida State’s Jimbo Fisher to replace ousted coach Kevin Sumlin.

Three weeks ago, an Orlando sports columnist ridiculed reports that A&M would target Fisher, especially when Fisher turned down LSU just two years previously.

“And if LSU is a lesser job than FSU, then Texas A&M is REALLY a lesser job than FSU,” wrote Mike Bianchi of the Orlando Sentinel. “At least at LSU, you are the king of an entire recruiting-rich state. At Texas A&M, you will always be the Texas Longhorns’ annoying kid brother.”

Well, Michael Corleone was Fredo’s kid brother. How’d that work out?

SEC Network analyst Greg McElroy also said in a radio interview that coaching A&M was not a “high-tier” job.

“Know who you are,” seems to be the message directed at A&M.

Actually, A&M is a “high-tier” job. Its impressive record of attracting and retaining coaches is proof. In the late ‘70s and early ‘80s, the University of Pittsburgh boasted one of the nation’s elite football programs. Pitt won the 1976 national championship. The Panthers finished among the Top Ten with 11-1 records in ’79, ’80 and ’81.

Yet, coach Jackie Sherrill left … for Texas A&M.

Gene Boyers
College Football Hall of Fame coach R.C. Slocum declined more than one high profile job to stay at Texas A&M.

Sherrill’s successor at A&M was R.C. Slocum, who led the Aggies to four conference championships and an undefeated season in ’94. Slocum was so successful he was offered head coaching positions at LSU and with the NFL’s Arizona Cardinals.

Yet, he remained at Texas A&M.

Slocum was eventually replaced by Dennis Franchione, who left Alabama after a 10-3 season in 2002 to come to Texas A&M.

In 2011, Sumlin led Houston to a 12-1 record and runner-up finish in Conference USA. Considered perhaps the hottest coaching prospect in the country, Sumlin could have accepted a position at UCLA or Arizona State.

He chose Texas A&M.

Some in the national media also seem to think A&M should not expect to win at a high level even though the Aggies have proven they can. A&M won 75 percent of its games during a five-year span in the ‘70s. The Aggies won three consecutive conference championships in the ‘80s. They also won three consecutive conference championships in the ‘90s.

That was accomplished without the elite facilities, administrative support and budget that A&M has now. The infrastructure, recruiting area, and — yes — even its history shows A&M can be an elite football program and a destination job for high-profile coaches.

All A&M needs is the right coach to bring it all together. Some in the national media need to learn who A&M really is.

Heisman leaders

Here are the weekly Heisman ratings based on how I’d vote if the ballot was due this week:

Mark D. Smith/USA Today Sports
Sooners QB Baker Mayfield's case for the Heisman is virtually indisputable.

1. Baker Mayfield, Oklahoma, QB: Not only did Mayfield pass for 281 yards and three touchdowns in a 59-31 victory over West Virginia, he also didn’t do anything embarrass himself or his team. Mayfield now has passed for 4,097 yards and 37 touchdowns.

2. Bryce Love, Stanford, RB: He had a typically productive outing in a 38-20 victory over Notre Dame. Love averaged 6.3 yards per carry while rushing for 125 yards. He has rushed for 1,848 yards and 16 touchdowns despite missing one game.

3. Jonathan Taylor, Wisconsin, RB: The Badgers fabulous freshman rushed for 149 yards and a touchdown in a 31-0 win over Minnesota. He’s exceeded 100 rushing yards in seven of the last eight games. Taylor has gained 1,806 yards and scored 13 touchdowns.

4. Lamar Jackson, Louisville, QB: Jackson was spectacular in a 44-17 victory over rival Kentucky. He passed for 216 yards and two touchdowns and rushed for another 156. He has thrown for 3,489 yards and rushed for 1,443 to lead the nation with 4,932 yards of total offense.

5. Kerryon Johnson, Auburn, RB: Johnson rushed for 105 yards and a touchdown in Auburn’s 26-14 victory over Alabama. He also completed a pass for a touchdown and caught three passes for 21 more yards. He’s rushed for 1,276 yards and 17 touchdowns despite missing two games.

Predicted playoff participants

1. Clemson: The Tigers have beaten three teams with eight wins, another (Virginia Tech) with nine and 10-win Auburn.

2. Oklahoma: A victory over possible Big Ten champion Ohio State is more impressive than a potential Big 12 championship.

3. Auburn: Two-loss teams won’t typically appear in the playoff. But two-loss teams typically haven’t posted consecutive wins over No. 1 teams like Auburn has in beating Georgia and Alabama.

4. Wisconsin: No one seems to respect the Badgers, but no one has beaten them either.

Discussion from...

Around CFB: Critics minimizing A&M's potential aren't paying attention

38,776 Views | 22 Replies | Last: 6 yr ago by Cotton79
Mr. Black
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Nicely done, Olin!
StickTogetherAgs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
UntoldSpirit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Couldn't agree more.
PaulSimonsGhost
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
"Well, Michael Corleone was Fredo's kid brother. How'd that work out?"


Boom goes the dynamite! Suck it Orlando.


Been reading your work for 20 years, Olin. Keep up the good job.
Racing is life. Anything before or after is just waiting.

Steve McQueen
Matsui
How long do you want to ignore this user?
gocobra
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MD20/20
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Auburn is about to be a three loss team.
Cooter Brown is my designated driver.
Agsuffering@bulaw
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yes! Thank you for pushing back, OB!
MetoliusAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Average nbr of wins per season is a function of coaching, plus program advantages.

f(x) + y = z

x is the head coach you hire.

y is the avg "floor" nbr of wins a program would get if it hired a braindead gerbil as its Head Coach. At a program like OhioSt with its program advantages, y=5. At a school like Kansas or Baylor, y=0.

z is the avg nbr of wins you get as a result of x and y.

Cuterebra
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
We are the sleepiest giant. zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
PabloSerna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yessir!
Meximan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Folks so easily forget that Sumlin was THE candidate to hire in all of college football in 2012. There was no hotter name to hire at that time, at least among exciting up-n-comers.
MostlyHarmless
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I get so tired of these idiots. And yes, I call them idiots because of the stupidity they keep spewing. Earlier today I read where one of them said that if Fisher didn't take the LSU job that there was no way he would take the A&M job because the LSU job was way better than A&M's. So clueless.

Let's take this out of the CF world for a moment. Let's say you are offered a job at a good company. The guy trying to hire you tells you about all the accomplishments of the people who have held the position you are interviewing for before you. They have performed the best in the country at times and now they want you try and do the same. Now he knows that you have that offer from the company across town. And he knows that at that company you have a bigger, nicer office with a better view. He also knows you will have a bigger budget to work with as well. That company has a nice fitness center and a gourmet cafeteria. And to top it all off they will pay you 25% more than his company is willing to pay. But hey, the last few people who held that position at this other company didn't perform at a very high level. And so he tells you that job is not nearly as good as the one he is offering you. Now, which job would you rather have?
94chem
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Little things. ..win the bidding war for Cam Newton, run a FG back 109 yards, complete an 80 yard Hail Mary, and you're in 2 national championship games and a top tier job.

Miss a FG against Florida, rush 3 against t.u., get Bucky hurt against Tulsa, and you're a "never was" who needs to stay in their lane.

I'm 100% sure that we can beat anybody. You'd be amazed what tackling a few people and going into attack mode on offense could do. Make the right hire and we will win big. This is a refocus, not a rebuild.
William_C_G
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Great article! TCU certainly doesn't know its place. And neither do we! We will be back!
Third Son
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wow thanks for the piece Olin. The quotes are funny, surprising, preposterous and puzzling all at once.
1st Generation Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What history does Texas A&M have? I'll tell you.

19 conference championships - In the SEC, only Alabama has more.

2 un-scored-upon teams - there have only been five in college football history.

3 national championships - irrespective of the fact that the AP became the definitive championship in 1936, there is no way you can award the championship to anyone else in 1917 or 1919 because, as I mentioned, they shut out every opponent those two years. That's something that Texas, Alabama, and Notre Dame will never accomplish. I don't know why we claim 1927 but not 1917.

2 Heisman trophies - same number as Alabama, who finally caught up to the Aggies when Derrick Henry won it in 2015.

All that with no elite facilities, tepid support from the state, an adversarial press stocked with graduates from our biggest rival, and the Longhorns using the state high school championships as their own farm system.

Look, I'm class of 2005. It's been 17 football seasons and I haven't witnessed a championship. If I had started any year prior to 1999, I would have seen one. Any aggie who started before 1994 would have seen multiple championships in his first 17 seasons. People forget that this is the longest championship drought in our history. That's why we're going after Jimbo Fisher.
KS80537
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Good article, and nice to see the unanimous agreement of the responses.

Sometimes I have to remind myself (and others) that it wasn't that long ago (from the perspective of a 45 year old) that A&M was a small, all-male military school. Night and day difference vs. the A&M of today. There is no ceiling on what A&M can accomplish athletically or academically. All the needed ingredients are there. Just need the right guy to put them all together.
Jarrin' Jay
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Those that say A&M is a lesser job or we should accept our current status don't know history or understand our potential, and they also do not look at similar programs or circumstances around the country.

A&M is one of the Top 20 winningest programs of all-time. A&M is one of the top bowl appearance teams of all time.

Good Bull Hunting had a good similar article (that I reference as I am not going to bother with the research): Prior to Carroll at USC the mighty Trojans had won 10 games something line one (1) time in the prior 15 years, until Clemson won the ACC in 2011 with Dabo they had not won a conference title since 1991 and their last 10 win season was 1988, prior to the arrival of Bobby Bowden at FSU in 1976 they had a good season in 1964 as an independent prior to that you have to go back to the 50s for any measure of success, etc. Even Barry Switzer thinks we should be much better and much more relevant than we are.

EVERYTHING is there for A&M to compete with Alabama and LSU for the West title and to be a perennial Top 25 program. I am not demanding SEC titles, I am demanding a consistent program that 4 out of 5 seasons ends the season ranked, routinely wins 9+ games, and plays meaningful games in November toward obtaining a conference title. Won't happen every year, but we should be a lot more like Auburn than Miss. State and Arkansas.
MetoliusAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bianchi is the Florida version of Mac Engel. He is a paid troll and gossip columnist.
AggieJon87
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Texas A&M is no one's KIDS Brother. Older, Large, Better. get it through your head. Don't parrot the ignorant masses that think Texas is older than us. Those young punks have tried to stab us in the back for decades. Time to show them who really runs things. ANd as for t.u. cograts on FINALLY making it to a bowl game.
Aggie Jon '87
Cotton79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
National sports media parade their ignorance AND their arrogance at the same time. I seem to recall many of the same voices - and a lot more - said similar dismissive things about A&M when we first joined the SEC. Then, Johnny and Kliff lit 'em up like a firecracker hidden in a cheap cigar.

I'm thinking a similar result is in order now.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.