Since Mark Johnson became head coach in 1986, the top players to not enroll after signing with the Aggies being have mainly been pitchers. That has continued with Rob Childress but he has lost some top offensive players as well.
If Clayton Kershaw was pitching for A&M the past two years, I know the Aggies would have been in the CWS at least once the past two seasons and probably twice but he might not have had the impact of another lefty that went in the first round.
LHP Brian Bohanon, the first round pick of the Texas Rangers in 1987, would have been the top pitcher in college baseball in the 1988-1990 seasons. He made the majors in just three years and it is hard to fathom what the record of the Aggies would have been those three years considering they went 153-39 without Bohanon on the mound. Two years the Aggies played in the regional championship game.
Others that come to mind that were actually going to enroll, unlike Josh Beckett who double signed with Blinn JC and had no intention to enroll, include LHP Josh Girdley in 2000, LHP Aaron Thompson in 2005, RHP Andy Yount in 1995 and LHP Robby Beckett in 1990.
As far as hitters go, Chip Ambres and Choo Freeman mixed in on a CWS team in 1999 would have certainly made a special team even better. Kelly Johnson would have certainly been the shortstop for the Aggies from 2001-03. Mark Farris would have been a star outfielder from 1995-97.
www.aggiebaseball.net