HVAC Repair Question - Did I screw up?

1,358 Views | 11 Replies | Last: 1 mo ago by EFR
sirhc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
(apologies on any terminology that might not be 100% correct)

I had the blower motor in my furnace go out last weekend. I called an AC repair company that had 24 hour service. They came out saturday night and confirmed it was the blower motor, but said they wouldnt be able to source the part until Monday. They said it was under warranty, (i would just owe labor) and that going through the manufacturer for the part would be the best route. Come Monday, it basically took them all day to find the part. Meanwhile I was asking for some sort of off brand/rescue motor, but they kept insisting that 1) they didn't know if they could find one faster that would work in my system (Lennox) and 2) it would void the warranty on my system.
Fast forward, it took them until Thursday to get the part in and repair my system, and I spent about 5 nights worth of hotel/airbnb waiting.


For those familiar with HVAC stuff - is what they told me correct? Are rescue motors unit specific anyways, and would using one void my warranty? Is there something I should do different next time? It was just coincidence that the company I called was a certified Lennox shop, but if I had called someone else, would they have had the resources to go through Lennox for the part, or would they have just slapped something off brand in there and I would have been repaired faster?
EMY92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Unless you have a variable speed blower motor, the motors are pretty generic. It wouldn't void the warranty to replace with a like motor. The motors are not OEM, Lennox buys them from motor manufacturers and it's not going to be unique.

Variable speed is a little different, but many years ago when I worked for Lennox, I had a dealer that installed a lot of ground source heat pumps (not Lennox), they would buy the variable speed motors to repair the blowers from Lennox, because they were cheaper.

The issue with not getting the motor warrantied, is you may be stuck paying for the motor, that would be much cheaper than a hotel.
Jason_Roofer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I am not an HVAC pro, as you can tell from my user name so everything that follows is my personal experience with this situation with three ac companies over the course of 3 years.

My experience with my own repairs on my own hvac is that you cannot just toss whatever you want in it. The manufacturers, as stated above, don't make their own motors but the motors do have to match and be programmed if they are ECM. THEY must match for model, airflow, profiles, etc. You don't have a PSC motor which I'm guessing is what you were asking them to put in and ECM motors require programming. For my warranty work, I have a good friend that is a tech so I pull my blower and motor and he handles the warranty on it and returns the motor. I have two versions of my ac system. I kept my old air handler in case I needed backup and I have needed it. One is a variable speed version and one is a fixed speed…BUT…both use ECM motors. They are not interchangeable. So, when one goes out, I have to swap out my entire blower assembly because the motor that goes with it has a board that goes with it and it is not interchangeable. I can't just throw whatever in it and it has been my experience twice with two companies that motors like this aren't just everywhere.

To me your experience is not unusual. Plus, there would need to be changes made to make a generic motor work and the tech would have to make those which would like mean the ac motor just runs 24/7. Then when your other part came in, he'd have to undo all of that.

The first company I used took16 days in August to get my first motor replaced under warranty. That's when I got up to speed on how to do it myself.

If I were you, I'd go get a portable AC unit and keep that on hand. I have two for my house and when my ac was out for two weeks, my bedrooms were like meat lockers.

sirhc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Thanks! I have thought about getting a portable AC (or 2) for the house for emergencies. Question on those - the part that connects to windows - its a cut it once and done right? I wouldn't be able to then take it to another room with a different size window?
Featured Video Previews
Rexter
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Most portables have a two-piece slider for the vent so it fits multiple windows.
When we were in the travel trailer for 3 months last year, I used the portable to help out the roof unit. The sliding vent was too big for the window, so I made one out of cardboard. No issues.
EMY92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The window AC I keep for emergencies has little corrugated slider that fills the window opening. It sucks, but if I keep the doors closed, I can get my bedroom nice and cold in the summer. I've also loaned it to neighbors when they've had HVAC issues.
Dill-Ag13
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
+1 window unit is good insurance if you have a single unit
Jason_Roofer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Someone already answered but to reiterate, it's adjustable and meant for temporary and multiple uses. You don't need to cut anything. It's super handy. I like the small window unit as well but they sort of have to be installed to some degree, but they take up less room and you could leave there if you wanted. Portables are nice but they take up more room and you need to store it somewhere.

Either way, for the price of either option, it's handy as hell.

We all actually sleep better with the portable units because they get the room ice cold, and they have a continuous white noise effect that just knocks me out.
tgivaughn
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
In Aggieland, we are used to sucking hind-T & leftovers from Houston suppliers, soooo SOP pal if not IN Houston.
That said, allowing BS flow from a problem solvers mouth to one suffering in this heat is NOT Google 5-stars and deserves a repost review on Google.

Agreed the only rescue item is the window AC .... we like LG on thermos & remote controllers and leave them installed! Insulation panels back up the accordians.
  • all glass rooms
  • West side hot BR for sleeping
    These lower the main HVAC work/costs in extremes, not to mention a single HVAC can freeze others trying to get a few degrees out of a single hot room
Gotta draw since me got no grammar MasterArch '76
sirhc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Thanks all. Sounds like the portable ac is the way to go for backup plan.

Hope to find one on sale this fall/winter
Dill-Ag13
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
They're on sale now. Also a used one on Facebook marketplace is a good play. Lots of people dump em as it starts to cool off and it's just going to rot in your attic/closet 98% of the time
EFR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
One note about the portable AC. Place the unit as close to the window as possible so the hose is as short as possible. The hose radiates a huge amount of heat so a long run of hose really cuts down on efficiency.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.