Real Estate
Sponsored by

Seeking thoughts, advice, views, etc.

1,646 Views | 14 Replies | Last: 1 day ago by aggiebrad94
KatyAggie2000
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
We bought a second home (Airbnb) during Covid (2020) on 30A (Florida panhandle). It's appreciated about 35%. We put 20% down. We are considering selling this house now (eerie feel a correction is coming) and using the proceeds to pay off our primary home (Katy, Tx). We have a great rate on the Katy property (2%) and have no interest in a 1031 (e.g., acquiring another rental, etc.). We're almost 50 and just like the idea of capitalizing while the market is still solid on 30A and being mortgage free. After taxes, real estate commission, etc. we could pay off our primary mortgage and still have a additional $50K to add to our rainy-day fund.

What if anything am I missing? I appreciate all feedback.

TIA.
goodbull92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Why pay off a 2% mortgage when you could invest the money & make way more than 2% on that money?
KatyAggie2000
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Good question. I'm not the most savvy investor and just like the idea and peace of mind not having a mortgage.
wessimo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
If you are risk averse you can use the proceeds to buy 10 year t bills paying 5% and come out 3% ahead.
Featured Video Previews
Yesterday
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The only benefit to that is you having piece of mind. Thats it. I would 100% put it n bonds and enjoy the extra cash you make. That said, your piece of mind is also important and if that's what you want then go for it.

Where is your place on 30a? We always look in that area.
Martin Q. Blank
How long do you want to ignore this user?
KatyAggie2000 said:

Good question. I'm not the most savvy investor and just like the idea and peace of mind not having a mortgage.
You're locking the money into your house and the only way to get it out is to either sell or refinance (at a much higher rate). If nothing else, just stick it in a high yield savings account.
Medaggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Depends on what is left on the loan. If it is small, I see no issues just taking that loan off your books. If it is more than about 100K, 2% makes little financial sense. If it helps you emotionally, go ahead.
Chipotlemonger
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
What value property in 30A is it? Seems to be a buyers market right now in places…lots of long listings and price drops, so you may not garner as much as you would have say 3 years ago. Or it may get you the same as it would have then. I guess what I'm saying is if you do sell, don't expect as m lm rage of a return right now with the economy going on as it is. In my amateur opinion.
KatyAggie2000
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Thanks all.

For more context, we owe $250K on our primary mortgage. Our agent has buyers interested in our place on 30A (Watersound) which will net us around $300K. This is also in line with recent sales. Yes, it would have been worth more a year or so ago, but still a nice increase since Covid.

I'm also losing my job next July after 26 years with the oil major I work for. This is due to a divestment, and I've decided not to go with the PE buyer. I'll have a pension and retirement healthcare but won't touch the pension for a handful of years. Paying off the mortgage would allow us to stay in our home (assuming I need to take a less paying job) vs. having to relocate for similar pay. Still have a kid that's a freshman in HS and he likes his school/friends.

From some of the above posts, we could put the $300K in a HYSA and let the money work for us. Fully get that. There's also the appeal of being able to liquidate the funds without having to sell our primary home. I get that too. Suppose we just need to somehow weigh these benefits over the peace of mind of no mortgage.

I really appreciate everyone taking the time to chime in.
JMac03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I agree, I wouldn't pay off your house.

Now our house is paid off so I don't really have a dog in the game because we had a very low interest rate as well BUT knowing what we know now, I would either invest, or at least do a HYSA to earn more $$.
MS08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
With earning potential still ahead of you, even after you move on for your job next July, and kids/kid is the house and (others in college?, and a 2% primary mortgage, there is no way, I would use up liquid cash to pay off 2% interest rate debt.

At minimum, higher yield savings account.
I believe government has an 8% yield bond option right now.
Or, you do a S&P indexed mutual fund.

Idea is for you to take your hard earned money and have it work for you. To me, paying off 2% debt doesn't accomplish that. We have had our mom nursing her sub 3% mortgage and investing to increase the nest egg and she is in her mid 70s and has not been working for over 10 years now.

How much total dollars is your actual interest a year? I would know that figure before making any decision.

Does your $300k injection include after your capital gains tax?
Also, does your AirBNB generate money? At least allow you to hold the property without paying for it? Plus generate a little bit more? Not sure what the Airbnb pulse is for 30A, but I would think people may be more willing to travel there via AirBNB instead of trying to buy a property (because of higher prices and 7% plus rates).

We all have different opinions and perspectives and ultimately our urge is, "you do you and what makes you feel most comfortable" but since you asked, it seems like you could be considering a sell decision that is more conservative and risk averse than what is necessary. It seems like this is a good offer, but not an offer that can't be refused, and I don't get the sense you "need to sell."

Spitballing.
ToddyHill
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

I'm not the most savvy investor and just like the idea and peace of mind not having a mortgage.

I've done really well in the stock market...have beaten the S&P 500 eight out of the last nine years. With that said, I fully agree with your thoughts of paying off your home. And after I read your post I knew I'd be in the minority...and that's OK.

We paid off our mortgage 9 years ago when my wife received a cash inheritance from her deceased mother. It comes down to qualitative or quantitative. Quantitative is obviously black & white, and I fully respect those who've shared their thoughts...that paying off the mortgage is not the right move.

You can become a savvy investor by finding the right professional planner. But also, I can't share the peace of mind we have, knowing our qualitative actions didn't makes sense to many, but we're good with that.

Sorry you're losing your job. Good luck with whatever you opt to do.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Even just putting that money in an X money account will get you 6%. There are loads of other high yield savings accounts out there that you can check out. Decent enough return without the uncertainty or volatility of the market.
rme
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sea Speed said:

Even just putting that money in an X money account will get you 6%. There are loads of other high yield savings accounts out there that you can check out. Decent enough return without the uncertainty or volatility of the market.

Agree with above.

"Paying off the mortgage would allow us to stay in our home (assuming I need to take a less paying job) vs. having to relocate for similar pay. "

This comment doesn't make any sense. Yes, selling the Florida property makes sense. Using the proceeds to pay off your mortgage hurts your liquidity. This may not be a big deal depending on your other liquid assets, but 2% is easy to beat.

Consider this from the cash flow perspective. Knowing your interest rate is incredibly low, would you pay $250,000 today to save $1,265 (pretend mortgage payment) a month for 20 years (pretend remaining loan life)?

aggiebrad94
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
KatyAg - I'd be glad to sit down with y'all and share some thoughts from my 30+ years as an investment advisor. I've seen your situation many, many times.

My folks are in a retirement home near IH-10 & Hwy 6 so we could meet nearby.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.