Real Estate
Sponsored by

illegal?

3,042 Views | 23 Replies | Last: 17 days ago by jokershady
jokershady
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
im suspicious that a realtor my mom is using e-signed for her on a contract. did some checking and sounds like this is a big no no.

i have an email with her realtor offering to sign on her behalf. worried about her getting taken advantage of as there's a lot more going on with her mental state that i'm going to avoid posting.

thoughts on how to handle this?
atmtws
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sounds like fraud. I'd confront him in person, and make sure his employer knows. Make damn sure he doesnt have the ability to pull this stunt again on anyone, def someone who doesnt have someone watching their back.

Im not an attorney, just a **** poster. Regardless, I dont think he can sign without power of attorney.
/W\ Saw 'Em Off! /W\
BTHO tu.
MS08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
No realtor should be signing on behalf of a seller or buyer. That's a no-no big time. You need to find out if that actually happened, if it did, report to broker and to trec.
jokershady
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm checking to see how I can confirm this happened tomorrow. I do have an email from the agent offering to sign on my mom's behalf and also within her email there is no e-sign email requesting her to sign the offer docs anywhere.

But I'm assuming there's more to it than that to prove this occurred.
Featured Video Previews
MS08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
That is the next step in discovery that I was going to suggest. With DocuSign, DotLoop, Adobe Esign, all electronic signature platforms that I am aware of, the electronic signature is requested by email to whoever is signing. So, if something is signed electronically (by your mom), but no email ever hit her inbox from an electronic signature platform, then that is probably a tell-tale sign that something shady went down.
HomeFinderCody
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sponsor
AG
Absolutely an event that should cause you to fire that agent immediately, report to broker, and report to TREC (at LEAST to broker). There is never justification to do that. Ever. It's fraud.
Sponsor Message: Need real estate help in North Texas? Click Here to Save $500
BrazosDog02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Check her sent items and see if she responded. I've dealt with more than my share of old people that know they can't get a document open for signature. In these cases I meet and sign in person in a device so there won't be an email link.

Either way you can use the tracking metrics on the signature page to see where it was signed. If it was signed in his office and she didn't do it in person then you have your answer.
dubi
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BrazosDog02 said:

Check her sent items and see if she responded. I've dealt with more than my share of old people that know they can't get a document open for signature. In these cases I meet and sign in person in a device so there won't be an email link.

Either way you can use the tracking metrics on the signature page to see where it was signed. If it was signed in his office and she didn't do it in person then you have your answer.

Does it track the device IP / MAC Address also?
jokershady
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BrazosDog02 said:

Check her sent items and see if she responded. I've dealt with more than my share of old people that know they can't get a document open for signature. In these cases I meet and sign in person in a device so there won't be an email link.

Either way you can use the tracking metrics on the signature page to see where it was signed. If it was signed in his office and she didn't do it in person then you have your answer.
There was no response. Likely a majority of their conversation took place over text and phone.

To give a timeline breakdown of things:

1:59 pm the realtor sends an email outlining the docs and asking my mom if she wants her (the realtor) to sign on her behalf or send the docs to her phone.

2:45 pm an email from her e-sign account (Skyslope Digisign) saying all docs have been completed. But in these docs there's no initials or signatures from my mom anywhere…just the few signatures that the realtor was needing to sign for…

There's no email indicating when the offer was submitted I just know it was done before 4:20 pm because that's when the realtor emailed the lender the docs to fill them in.

No emails requesting my mom's signature hit her inbox at anytime.

I feel like there's enough here to report to TREC regardless since she:

1. Offered to sign on her behalf with no POA
2. No e-sign requests were sent to her inbox

But…I'm slow playing this. There's still more going on than I care to let on and I know the sellers (unless they change their mind) won't be making decisions until this weekend and on top of that if it is accepted there's a 7 day option period. And I have the title company info.

Needless to say though this is stressful as hell…..
dubi
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

1. Offered to sign on her behalf with no POA

That is illegal also.
BrazosDog02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Unless these are docs that only the realtor initials, it's bad juju.

I respect your decision to slow play this, but I think I would rather just get ahead of it sooner than later. Depending on what it is, in the state of Texas contract can be canceled within three days. No harm no foul, and you can still go after the Realtor for any legal wrongdoing.
MS08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I wouldn't trust the realtor. They messed up, either intentionally or accidentally. Either way they are not someone that I would want on my team when transacting real estate. Who knows what other shady stuff is happening specific to this property that they are a part of
jokershady
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Whelp…not that I needed it but I ended up getting verbal confirmation of everything that I suspected was true regarding the realtor signing for my mom with only a text message for permission and no signed POA.

I've already started writing up the TREC complaint and I'm taking my time making sure I get everything right and am being very precise regarding the exact documents and dates.

I guess what I'm looking for is just re-assurance that I'm doing the right thing (even though I've already read and appreciate all that's been said on this thread thus far). Never done anything like this and I know the fur is gonna fly once this snowball starts but I don't care about the fireworks.

This is not fun at all….
SteveBott
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This is a gut issue and it's usually right.
JMac03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Does this help your mom get out of the deal? I saw your other post. I agree, you are doing the right thing if someone signed on her behalf.
HomeFinderCody
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sponsor
AG
Bottom line is this - if that agent is willing to do something this shady, what is is he/she willing to do, or what else have they already done? It's just bad business. I'd move on immediately.

There are many good agents out there (way more bad ones though) so finding a competent, honest, credible one to replace the bad one is certainly possible.
Sponsor Message: Need real estate help in North Texas? Click Here to Save $500
jokershady
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Appreciate the kind words. My mom wants the house. Issue is cognitively she's not there anymore. A hoarder who spends $200k + on crap she doesn't need in roughly 3 years and then decides she needs a new house in order to clean up an older one, isn't thinking clearly.

Complaint to TREC was submitted about 20 minutes ago. E-mailed Title about 10 minutes after that.

So fur is gonna fly here....but this won't stop her from buying a house if she really wants to. She could easily just go find another realtor, have them write up the same docs as this current deal, and move forward again as long as she actually signs them.
jokershady
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
For those curious about what's been going on...had a bit of a break through today...

On top of having a recording of my mom admitting what happened and uploading several e-mails about what occurred, got a gift today...

The dumb ***** admitted what she had done in an e-mail from Title. Earlier today Title sent an e-mail to her filling her in on my informing that the documents were not signed by the buyer but by the buyers agent, and that Title would need all documents re-done.

In her reply, she basically says yes that's correct but then tries to justify it by saying she received in writing from my mom that it was ok.

No! You stupid ****! If it was ok then Title wouldn't be asking for all the documents to be re-done would they? Idiot! A text message isn't the same thing as a signed and notarized POA!

So needless to say I've already uploaded this e-mail and a separate summary of said email in a word doc to the portal for my complaint to TREC.

Unreal! Sorry for the language but this whole scenario of my mom going off the rails has been so frustrating so seeing this e-mail admitting it at least gives me some satisfaction from this whole dang mess.
ToddyHill
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
My wife has been a Realtor for 15 years in Tennessee. I can't begin to count the number of realtors she's dealt with that should have had the license pulled over illegal actions. So sorry for your issues...but it sounds like you've done the right thing.

Keep up posted please!
yocod
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I mean, we're talking about an industry with very little barrier to entry. It is nuts that you can advise people on the biggest financial decision of their life with the only qualification being a high school education/GED and passing a few classes. There are even some "schools" that offer pass-or-don't-pay promotions lol. Oh, add to that, it's a commission based system, which inherently puts the agent's interest ahead of their client. Sorry you're going through this. I'd consider talking with an attorney as well and exploring any options there. As for your mom, that is a tough position. It could be worth exploring a conservatorship if you're very concerned. Best of luck going forward.
ToddyHill
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The laws have changed. It's up to the seller to offer any compensation to the buyer's agent. If they choose not to offer compensation, the buyer needs to pay their realtor. The law changed about a year ago.
Jason_Roofer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Real estate, like any commission type of job is what you make of it. When I got my license many years ago, the barrier to entry is low but I will say that I was nervous during all tests. The big one at the end made me nervous and I don't remember my score and I don't recall it being overly difficult.

These types of jobs, much like my current industry, are heavily dependent on experience and many folks who get into real estate or roofing are looking for an easy buck, or a side gig. It is my opinion that you can't be good or great when you treat it as a side gig. We can all take a test and get the answers but working with customers, predicting problems and making them non issues, and knowing all the ins and outs when things get tricky or nuanced is where the agent shines. That ONLY comes from experience. I can tell you the caliber of student in Champions RE School was heavily biased toward subpar. It was very easy to see the 2-5 students who were serious about making it a career.

Because of that, roofing and real estate ….. everyone knows a guy. In my company we have over 200 guys across the country managing roof projects. Yet myself and about 10 others are the top producers for the company. It's the same guys. Every year. The same ones that have been doing it for a decade or more. They always answer the phone or return calls, they have repeated business, they just outwork the ones that was an easy buck. There is no easy buck.
atmtws
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
You did the right thing. You caught it this time, and luckily your mom still wants the house. But you may have also prevented this from happening to someone else in similar situations, who has nobody to be their advocate that prevents them from getting fleeced.

/W\ Saw 'Em Off! /W\
BTHO tu.
jokershady
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Whelp, transaction went belly up. Saw my mom had signed her Buyers Option To Terminate Contract yesterday and the house was already back to Active later that day.

Don't know what occurred and honestly don't care all that much. Bottom line is crisis adverted (so far) and now got to see how open she is to communicating with me.

My TREC complaint is still under "Initial Review" but I'm taking a slightly educated guess that it will advance to whatever the "Supervisory Review" stage is.

Has anyone here actually put in a complain with TREC before on their online portal?
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.