Texas A&M Football
Sponsored by

If duke wins

4,024 Views | 35 Replies | Last: 4 mo ago by twk
biglebowski
How long do you want to ignore this user?
They do not necessarily get in right? Since they wouldn't be the highest ranked conference champion of all others? Other conference champions would be ranked higher.
Gig’em
Wabs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If Duke wins, JMU gets in (assuming they win their CCG). Duke is not getting in with a win.
BMX Bandit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
correct. the 5 highest conference champions get in.

Duke and JMU are both currently not ranked. Don't be surprised if Duke shows up in the rankings this week and gets a bump to that 5th conference champ if they win.
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
They will probably put Miami in if that happens. No way they are not having an ACC rep in the playoffs.
RoadkillBBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What a complete embarrassment for the ACC. The fact this is even a possibility and they fail to have any teams ranked 1-12 at this point makes that conference a complete joke. They should be regulated to G5 status as punishment.
Wabs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Logos Stick said:

They will probably put Miami in if that happens. No way they are not having an ACC rep in the playoffs.

Then who you leaving out?

If JMU wins:

OSU
IU
UGA
Tard
Oregon
A&M
Ole Miss
JMU
Tulane/North TX

If they put Miami in that's 10 teams and leaves 2 spots for Alabama, ND, OU.
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ND since they lost to Miami.
Wabs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Logos Stick said:

ND since they lost to Miami.

Certainly possible, but it would be wild to see ND left out. They may just bend over OU instead.
aggiehawg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
RoadkillBBQ said:

What a complete embarrassment for the ACC. The fact this is even a possibility and they fail to have any teams ranked 1-12 at this point makes that conference a complete joke. They should be regulated to G5 status as punishment.

ACC sold their soul to get the ND "affiliation" without being a conference member. That resulted in the awkward scheduling where depending on the year, conference games are not counted as conference games for purposes of which teams go to the CCG. All to accommodate ND's demands.

Hence, a four/five loss Duke is in the CCG. ACC screwed themselves.
NyAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Logos Stick said:

They will probably put Miami in if that happens. No way they are not having an ACC rep in the playoffs.


Miami would have to be an at large

They'd then gave to replace another st large: either nd or bama

I don't think they will do that, but you never know

The logical
One is nd because of the head to head

But then you'd have an nd team ranks ahead of Miami all along suddenly booted in the final poll because the powers that be don't wa t the acc left out

I don't think it happens because notre dame brings way more eyeballs than anyone in the acc


Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wabs said:

Logos Stick said:

ND since they lost to Miami.

Certainly possible, but it would be wild to see ND left out. They may just bend over OU instead.


Perhaps, but messing with OU is messing with the SEC. Sankey might not take too kindly to it. The committee would have decent justification for Miami over ND.
twk
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BMX Bandit said:

correct. the 5 highest conference champions get in.

Duke and JMU are both currently not ranked. Don't be surprised if Duke shows up in the rankings this week and gets a bump to that 5th conference champ if they win.

While the committee has made some questionable decisions, nothing they have done to date would approach putting a 7-5 team, that lost to Illinois, Tulane, and UConn, in the top 25. I think we can rule that out. At least I hope so.
Ugly
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wabs said:

If Duke wins, JMU gets in (assuming they win their CCG). Duke is not getting in with a win.

Honestly, I don't think the committee lets a second G5 team get in over an ACC team, so I bet they pull shenanigans after conference championships are over if they have to. They'll use some BS like "Duke got a win over a ranked team in the championship game and JMU didn't." if they have to.
RoadkillBBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
NyAggie said:

Logos Stick said:

They will probably put Miami in if that happens. No way they are not having an ACC rep in the playoffs.


Miami would have to be an at large

They'd then gave to replace another st large: either nd or bama

I don't think they will do that, but you never know

The logical
One is nd because of the head to head

But then you'd have an nd team ranks ahead of Miami all along suddenly booted in the final poll because the powers that be don't wa t the acc left out

I don't think it happens because notre dame brings way more eyeballs than anyone in the acc




Bama was bumped out of the #11 slot last year for #16 Clemson. If they get bumped out for a 2nd year in a row the uproar will be biblical.
twk
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Bama was bumped out of the #11 slot last year for #16 Clemson. If they get bumped out for a 2nd year in a row the uproar will be biblical.

Clemson won the ACC and got the auto bid. Same thing could happen this year, but it would be because of the Big XII and not the ACC. The cut line for at large teams to make the field this year is 10 if Tech wins the Big XII. However, if BYU wins, it effectively becomes 9. So, absent a win against UGA, or being magically moved up in this week's rankings to 9 over ND (and then watch the ND vs Miami conflict rage), Bama is squarely on the bubble and has to hope that Tech wins in Arlington.
carl spacklers hat
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Logos Stick said:

ND since they lost to Miami.

First game of the year, played at Miami, with a circus catch for Miami to win it. No way Miami gets in, or even deserves to be in, over ND.
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Circus catches count.
Hill08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BMX Bandit said:

correct. the 5 highest conference champions get in.

Duke and JMU are both currently not ranked. Don't be surprised if Duke shows up in the rankings this week and gets a bump to that 5th conference champ if they win.


Absolutely ZERO chance Duke is ranked today….ZERO
DL76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Recap
9 FBS Conferences and their champions are eligible for the CFP. The highest 5 ranked conference champs receive auto bids provided they are in the CFP Top 25.
ACC
American
Big Ten
Big 12
Conference USA
MAC
Mountain West
Sun Belt
SEC
Because of current ranking, Big 10, Big 12, and SEC champs get in.

There are two other conferences teams in the Top 25 not CFP, but AP and Coaches Polls.

Assuming these polls translate to CFP, ACC's Virginia (#16) and the Sun Belt's James Madison (#19) have a shot. Virginia can secure an auto bid by beating Duke in the ACC Championship. A Duke win will unlikely get them in the CFP. James Madison can secure a bid by beating Troy in the Sun Belt Championship.
NyAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
twk said:

Quote:

Bama was bumped out of the #11 slot last year for #16 Clemson. If they get bumped out for a 2nd year in a row the uproar will be biblical.

Clemson won the ACC and got the auto bid. Same thing could happen this year, but it would be because of the Big XII and not the ACC. The cut line for at large teams to make the field this year is 10 if Tech wins the Big XII. However, if BYU wins, it effectively becomes 9. So, absent a win against UGA, or being magically moved up in this week's rankings to 9 over ND (and then watch the ND vs Miami conflict rage), Bama is squarely on the bubble and has to hope that Tech wins in Arlington.


Yep

TexasAggie81
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wabs said:

If Duke wins, JMU gets in (assuming they win their CCG). Duke is not getting in with a win.

Or the winner of Tulane / North Texas.
Maroon Flash
How long do you want to ignore this user?
"Perhaps, but messing with OU is messing with the SEC. Sankey might not take too kindly to it. The committee would have decent justification for Miami over ND."

Snakey is corrupt, spineless, and gutless. He will rubber stamp whatever espin wants.
Maroon Flash
Wabs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TexasAggie81 said:

Wabs said:

If Duke wins, JMU gets in (assuming they win their CCG). Duke is not getting in with a win.

Or the winner of Tulane / North Texas.

JMU and the Tulane/North Texas winner would both get in. The top 5 ranked conference champions get in. If Duke wins (and JMU wins), JMU will be ranked higher than them and eliminate the ACC bid.
James Earl Rudder
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Perfect opportunity to pair ND and tu in a bowl game for the NCAA Prima Donnas. ND would give them 150 yards of Love and give them loss numero quatro.

The Mediocrity Bowl
The Pillow-fight Bowl
The Do You Know Who you're Talking to? Bowl
The Drama Bowl




itsyourboypookie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
RoadkillBBQ said:

NyAggie said:

Logos Stick said:

They will probably put Miami in if that happens. No way they are not having an ACC rep in the playoffs.


Miami would have to be an at large

They'd then gave to replace another st large: either nd or bama

I don't think they will do that, but you never know

The logical
One is nd because of the head to head

But then you'd have an nd team ranks ahead of Miami all along suddenly booted in the final poll because the powers that be don't wa t the acc left out

I don't think it happens because notre dame brings way more eyeballs than anyone in the acc




Bama was bumped out of the #11 slot last year for #16 Clemson. If they get bumped out for a 2nd year in a row the uproar will be biblical.


Bama is bumped if they lose regardless.
Ag1188
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wabs said:

TexasAggie81 said:

Wabs said:

If Duke wins, JMU gets in (assuming they win their CCG). Duke is not getting in with a win.

Or the winner of Tulane / North Texas.

JMU and the Tulane/North Texas winner would both get in. The top 5 ranked conference champions get in. If Duke wins (and JMU wins), JMU will be ranked higher than them and eliminate the ACC bid.
This is correct and widely reported. I take it Op or whoever says otherwise hasn't watched any football analysis since the weekend. Miami isn't even in the conversation anymore.
Ag1188
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Bama is bumped if they lose regardless.
nope. Both, BYU would have to win and Alabama would have to lose for Alabama to be kicked out.
amercer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Three loss Bama is going to get the boot.

ND is too valuable. OU beat Bama
Wabs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
amercer said:

Three loss Bama is going to get the boot.

ND is too valuable. OU beat Bama

That will be the end to Conference Champ games then. I'm ok with that.
twk
How long do you want to ignore this user?
amercer said:

Three loss Bama is going to get the boot.

ND is too valuable. OU beat Bama

Bama isn't going to be left out of the field because they lose to UGA. If they stay at 10 tonight, they won't drop a spot for losing the SECCG. The only way they get left out of the field is if BYU beats Tech and steals an at large bid, in which case the last at large team in the field will be the 9 seed (currently Notre Dame).
Panama Red
How long do you want to ignore this user?
amercer said:

Three loss Bama is going to get the boot.

ND is too valuable. OU beat Bama


Alabama routinely outdraws Notre Dame on television. They are more valuable.

Twk got it right
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
IMHO, the 2nd place SEC team is not getting booted regardless of who it is and regardless of the B12 outcome.
aggiehawg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Bama isn't going to be left out of the field because they lose to UGA. If they stay at 10 tonight, they won't drop a spot for losing the SECCG. The only way they get left out of the field is if BYU beats Tech and steals an at large bid, in which case the last at large team in the field will be the 9 seed (currently Notre Dame).

Why does everybody walk backwards into a room, tube of KY Jelly taped to their back when it comes to ND?

ND is not an indy. Nor or they a conference member. They cannot play in the ACC CCG because they play so few actual ACC conference games but they are still eligible for at large bid in the playoffs?

Screw that noise. ND needs to crap or get off of the pot on conference membership.
twk
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggiehawg said:

Quote:

Bama isn't going to be left out of the field because they lose to UGA. If they stay at 10 tonight, they won't drop a spot for losing the SECCG. The only way they get left out of the field is if BYU beats Tech and steals an at large bid, in which case the last at large team in the field will be the 9 seed (currently Notre Dame).

Why does everybody walk backwards into a room, tube of KY Jelly taped to their back when it comes to ND?

ND is not an indy. Nor or they a conference member. They cannot play in the ACC CCG because they play so few actual ACC conference games but they are still eligible for at large bid in the playoffs?

Screw that noise. ND needs to crap or get off of the pot on conference membership.

It is rather annoying. If the Big Ten does this payday loan deal they've been talking about, maybe the ACC would be brave enough to tell ND it's time to fish or cut bait. The ACC likely wouldn't be facing the possibility of a 7-5 team winning the conference if they had a normal conference setup with 9 games played, and if the ACC makes ND choose, where do they do? They need a conference home for all their other sports, even if they think football can stay independent.
aggiehawg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

It is rather annoying. If the Big Ten does this payday loan deal they've been talking about, maybe the ACC would be brave enough to tell ND it's time to fish or cut bait. The ACC likely wouldn't be facing the possibility of a 7-5 team winning the conference if they had a normal conference setup with 9 games played, and if the ACC makes ND choose, where do they do? They need a conference home for all their other sports, even if they think football can stay independent.

My understanding back in the day that ND didn't want to join the B1G because of their research arms being up in every, member's bizness. IDK is that is still the case, though. Even the service academies are in a conference these days. Special exceptions for ND need to end.
Page 1 of 2
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.