Saw First and McCulloch and went with McCulloch.
I've had multiple surgeries both orth-o related and for cancer. My barometer for picking a surgeon between 2 equally qualified is to judge on bed-side manner. I ask a question that I've either already asked or ask a seemingly dumb question to see how the doctor handles it.
McCulloch was far more patient answering my questions, so I knew throughout my recovery, I would have for me, better access to information, etc...McCulloch was also more willing to spend extra time in the exam room prior to the surgery making sure all of my "regular" questions were sufficiently answered.
He did a major surgery on me over 5 years ago, and I'm doing great.
I'd have McCulloch cut on me again if necessary.
"The best social program is a job."
-Ronald Reagan
http://www.marchforbabies.com/