Aggieland
Sponsored by

Midtown promises question

4,319 Views | 53 Replies | Last: 5 days ago by UhOhNoAgTag
Brian Alg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
In another thread it was mentioned that folks in Midtown had been "promised a LOT by the developer". I have heard this kind of thing mentioned in other contexts (people speaking at city council meetings, probably some comment in a KBTX article). But I got the impression it might have been realtors saying it. It might be a game of telephone thing. I am not sure.

Were these promises put in writing or posted somewhere? I am wondering what was promised, who promised it, when it was promised, when whatever it was was supposed to happen, who was supposed to do it, etc. Does anyone have any insight into this? Even specifics from y'all's recollection would be helpful. So far, all I have heard is pretty vague.
Brian Alg

My words are not intended to be disrespectful to any of the staid and venerable members of College Station City Council
befitter
How long do you want to ignore this user?
James Murr has been driving the Midtown development train for well over a decade. Good place to start.
localag0165
How long do you want to ignore this user?
There have been many things said over the years, from the city and the developer. The only thing in writing is the City's Medical District plan that got renamed Midtown. They pushed it hard and I think the developer and the Midtown residents relied on it. It included a lot of promises of upgraded infrastructure, amenities, and public private partnerships. The city also promised the baseball fields many years ago, and they were supposed to go right next to Midtown, but after ~5 years of promising it they messed it up. Then, they tried to move it to Veterans Park with only 3 fields, and recently decided to move it back to Midtown but further away and in the first public private partnership the city has done. So, 10 years later we might get the baseball fields. Go look up the Medical District master plan the city created back in 2012. It was the driving force for all of this.
Aggie_Fire
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This should help too, to understand why Midtown residents are upset. Keep in mind they pay higher taxes to live there, and are rightfully angry.

http://midtowncitycenter.com/
Featured Video Previews
maddiedou
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Some guy said they went from .50 per 100 to .65 per 100

If my math is correct and I assume most houses are 500-1 million thats another 3300-6500 a year on top of property taxes

What is the draw for that much additional tax or is that homeowner dues
maddiedou
b0ridi
How long do you want to ignore this user?
maddiedou said:



I assume most houses are 500-1 million

Way off
maddiedou
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
b0ridi said:

maddiedou said:



I assume most houses are 500-1 million

Way off



Okay. 1 million to 5 million

6500-30,000 extra a year for what HOA dues
maddiedou
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It was .50 per $100 from the beginning. It didn't seem bad because the developer out a plan that showed retail and restaurants around the lake. Walkable from homes. Then 2 years ago, after it was obvious there would be no retail, restaurants, etc, they raised the rate to .65 per $100. We found out by the Board putting a notice in the Bryan Eagle. No notice to the homeowners directly. The Board, which I'm sure are all buddies of said developer, said the increase was necessary to "finish out the neighborhood". And now we are seeing streets named Murr and Dorothy. Nothing commercial.

When the rate increased to .65 that's when the homeowners started grumbling. It is was a huge increase with no homestead exemptions. Then the developer started blaming the City for things he was "promised" going back 10 years. He blamed COVID, construction cost and impact fees, the city.

And just last year COCS put "affordable housing" in the neighborhood. Who knows what is next.

doubledog
How long do you want to ignore this user?


We were promised a chicken in every pot, now it comes in buckets.

maddiedou
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
UhOhNoAgTag said:

It was .50 per $100 from the beginning. It didn't seem bad because the developer out a plan that showed retail and restaurants around the lake. Walkable from homes. Then 2 years ago, after it was obvious there would be no retail, restaurants, etc, they raised the rate to .65 per $100. We found out by the Board putting a notice in the Bryan Eagle. No notice to the homeowners directly. The Board, which I'm sure are all buddies of said developer, said the increase was necessary to "finish out the neighborhood". And now we are seeing streets named Murr and Dorothy. Nothing commercial.

When the rate increased to .65 that's when the homeowners started grumbling. It is was a huge increase with no homestead exemptions. Then the developer started blaming the City for things he was "promised" going back 10 years. He blamed COVID, construction cost and impact fees, the city.

And just last year COCS put "affordable housing" in the neighborhood. Who knows what is next.





That is a bunch of hogwash and how is this not a legal issue of raising another .15 cents and I guess I was wrong on the 1-5 million homes if affordable housing is going in but I guess you really do not have to worry about that with a additional tax upon a tax Thats not affordable housing


Who is this developer
maddiedou
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
James Murr. And the president of the RPMD2 is Uri (Bombers owner). Mark at Sveciks and Logan Lee other directors, plus 2 other guys. They are clueless what the 30% increase did when the value of the homes have gone down.

The neighborhood is primarily 1st time buyers and rental property and retirees. However, there are some Kaleo Homes that are valued over $500-700k. DR Horton just closed our their homes.


maddiedou
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Clueless is a understatement

And I am sorry for people who bought there but why would a major system like that be built around DR horton homes

I am shocked now from what the development should have been I would have thought shafer/ellis/easterling/marriot. Would have been the builders

I am talking about something that I know nothing about so I am going to stop because I really jave no clue. Just that .65/100 makes me mad

edit
EVEN if it is homeowner dues thats crazy 650 a year eztra for a 100,000 dollar house

Uhoh.

I hope somebody figures this out and that printing the name of the Board members is a start
maddiedou
91_Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I still can't kayak on that lake and I'm pi553d
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
There is a sign that says "No trespassing, park under construction". LOL, what construction.

Plus we have a $500 HOA dues. It was $750. No pool, no amenities, but it pays for overpriced CEO/Arrive fiber another LOL.
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Oh and they have HOA meetings at 2 pm so people who work can't attend.
hydes11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
For what it's worth, the City isn't exempt of any fault here. They're the ones that created said taxing district and then did nothing to help the area succeed.

Not a great strategy on their part.
AggiePhil
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
maddiedou said:

b0ridi said:

maddiedou said:



I assume most houses are 500-1 million

Way off



Okay. 1 million to 5 million.

No way the houses there cost that much. They are primarily starter homes.
wareagle044
How long do you want to ignore this user?
maddiedou said:

Clueless is a understatement

And I am sorry for people who bought there but why would a major system like that be built around DR horton homes

I am shocked now from what the development should have been I would have thought shafer/ellis/easterling/marriot. Would have been the builders

I am talking about something that I know nothing about so I am going to stop because I really jave no clue. Just that .65/100 makes me mad and i am glad I guess for homeowner dues

Uhoh.

I hope somebody figures this out and that printing the name of the Board members is a start


It was always a little surprising to me the houses that were put there with the proposed development.

Would it have gotten more attention to become what was actually proposed had they been more custom style homes in that $500k-$1M range?
birdman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
$500k for those houses on miniscule lots? No chance. And the value will be dropping. They were slapped together.
maddiedou
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
birdman said:

$500k for those houses on miniscule lots? No chance. And the value will be dropping. They were slapped together.


I kinda know where the area is now that somebody has given a location but I just assumed that since they the dang city and developer were talking about making it a destination place you would have assumed it was at least the 500plus homes on 1/2 acres to showcase the area somewhat and not DR horton homes on top of each other and now discussing affordable housing


I am the furtherest person to tell you what to buy or not to buy but to be lied to that is a whole different ball of wax and the amount of extra tax yall are paying

Also one last question. Why is it yalls responsibility to further the midtown with extra dues

Who is the developer again
maddiedou
Gunner0740
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I just looked at realtor.com and the houses are listed from between 225k-360k on that platform. I have seen the flyers in some of the homes with some floor plans being in the 400s.
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Look up houses on Calaveras Ct.

1000 Calaveras Ct, College Station, TX 77845 [Updated 10/26] https://share.google/RANIaR8B00Anh6YME

https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/1048-Calaveras-Ct-College-Station-TX-77845/463340572_zpid/?utm_campaign=androidappmessage&utm_medium=referral&utm_source=txtshare
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The $500K homes are quarter of an acre.
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
JAMES MURR
EFR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Who is really at fault here?
Did the city not build the promised infrastructure?
Did the developers not build amenities and attract the commercial tenants they hoped?
Did realtors over promise to make a sale?
Did the home buyers look at everything with rose colored glasses even though the city/developers/realtors have a long history of over promising and under delivering?
maddiedou
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Very good questions
maddiedou
Hornbeck
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
EFR said:

Who is really at fault here?
Did the city not build the promised infrastructure?
Did the developers not build amenities and attract the commercial tenants they hoped?
Did realtors over promise to make a sale?
Did the home buyers look at everything with rose colored glasses even though the city/developers/realtors have a long history of over promising and under delivering?


Usually, there is plenty of blame to go around in situations like this. I'm inclined to believe that the city did not live up to what they promised. I feel bad for the folks paying an extra $0.65 per $100 and don't get much for their return.

Does the city get that money or the developer? How does that work?
maddiedou
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
But James Murr should never depend on the devil

James Murr should know how the city operates by now and being a real estate guy

Also why would the city help James Murr out if they were going to help it should have been in some kinda tax break

The city should not be helping James Murr out that promised to citizens a crap load of amenities that James Murr has not provided especially at a dang 50 cent per 100 per year

Can somebody figure out roughly the tax appraisal for that area. Holy crap I just thought of something the way the appraisal district is appraising some of these house may have seen an increase over 100 percent in appraisal which would cause their dues to go up also

Lets say the appraisal for that area again dont know 100 houses at 300,000 Thats like 2 million in unnecessary tax revenue for nothing or maybe thats landscaping dues
maddiedou
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The original plan was for there to be around 675 homes. In 2023 ish, they added more property and now there are predicting close to 1,000. They added the additional property again without notifying original homeowners. Or they may have published it in the Bryan Eagle. LOL. And it was after that they they raised the rate 30%.

I wish there was more transparency with the Board. Their meetings are at 2 pm as well. And they are the ones who decide to issue bonds (based on what the developer wants) which is what we are paying for. The request goes to COCS City council which only shows up on the consent agenda and it is never pulled out for discussion. So now we are in for over $15 million in bonds. Who is supposed to pay for roads and infrastructure anyway?
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Goes back to the developer.
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
There is some type of agreement where the developer is supposed to build 150,000 sf of non-residential and then he gets the money in the special account. I guess he's only built the little office suites. And those were built in 2019.
maddiedou
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
With a 1000 house would that not be like 20 million a year for hoa dues
Or
James Murr and BOD retirement fund

Where is everybody to help me on this. I am the worst at asking the right questions and trying to figure this out
maddiedou
UhOhNoAgTag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HOA dues are different that the RPMD2 taxes. $500 a year for HOA plus .65 cents per $100 for RPMD2 taxes.
Hornbeck
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ok, so, the developer paid for all the roads, the lake, etc., etc., up front. The county appraisal district is holding this extra tax in a "special account" until he builds 150k sq ft of non-residential property?

If I were him, I'd build a big storage facility, and cash in on that account?!

I guess I'm kinda confused as to how the "amenities" get built.

More questions than answers.
AgGunNut
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
IDK that I feel sorry at all for someone buying a DR house just to pay an extra tax that they know about ahead of time. Going up the extra $.15, yeah, that's crappy.

Same reason I'd never buy at Southern Pointe (even if they do actually have some amenities). People need to do research before buying.
Page 1 of 2 ▼
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.