Outdoors
Sponsored by

Hoyt vs Matthews

7,746 Views | 24 Replies | Last: 3 yr ago by Zheinsohn
Zheinsohn
How long do you want to ignore this user?
In the market for a new bow, wanting to get some opinions.
Do you you prefer Hoyt or Matthews?
Not really set on specific models at the moment share your preferences.
HUEY04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
These days they both make equally good bows and it just comes down to your personal preferences and fit. I say that as the owner of 4 Hoyt bows including a 2022 RX-7 Ultra. Back in 2008 when I first got serious about archery Hoyt was the obvious choice because of their superior cam system, grips, and general fit and finish. Now they both have basically the same cam systems, limb geometry, grip geometry, fit/finish, and features. I picked the Hoyt because of the better fit with the longer available axle to axle and because the RX-7 Ultra was just way better than any other hunting bow I've ever tried at my draw length.
agingcowboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I've been a fan of Matthews for many years. Always just felt good in my hand. I then opened up an archery shop and our bow lines were Elite, Prime, and Bowtech. (Our competitor had Hoyt/Matthews). At that point, I got stuff at cost and sometimes free so I became a Bowtech fan. Fast forward to a few years ago, I've sold my bow shop and my equipment is due to be upgraded. I was faced with having to go pay retail. I went to a reputable bow shop and shot every one of their new, high end bows. I went into it thinking I would go with Hoyt. But after shooting Bowtech, Hoyt, Matthew's, Prime, PSE. I ended up with a new Mathews bow. I'm older now and it just felt the best fit for my hand, smoothest cycle, least handshock, etc. I'd go shoot them both and all the rest and see what you like.
Howdy Dammit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Hoyt Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Mathews sucks.


*I own a v3x as a backup bow to my RX5 primary bow.
JDGS612
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I own two Hoyts (Carbon Element, Spyder 30). Shot both Hoyt and Mathew's along with some others (Bowtech, Element) prior to buying my first Hoyt. To me the draw cycle on the Hoyt was so much smoother and the bows felt "deader" in my hand when I released the arrow. I do agree that there are many quality bow manufacturers out there now and you should shoot as many as you need to until you find the one that feels good to you. I'd have ZERO problem recommending Hoyt to anyone though.
BCO07
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Go shoot a bunch of different bows and see what you like the best. I went in to live oak archery with plan to buy the flagship level Matthews and walked out with a bowtech. I also shot a hoyt and pse and went with what felt the best.
killbutchereat
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Mathews is way better than Hoyt. Just ask me, I shoot a Mathews. Please do not consult Hoyt Ag for his opinions.
Pinche Guero
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Don't sleep on Bowtech and PSE. Like others have said, go shoot some and see what you like. I'm currently shooting a Bowtech solution and really like it.
agwrestler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I've worked on a ton of bows part time in a shop and owned a few:
Bear Whitetail
Elite GT500
Elite Impulse 31
Elite Impulse 34
Bear Apprentice
Strother Hope
Diamond Atomic
Diamond Atomic
Elite Answer
Hoyt Charger
Hoyt Rukus
Hoyt Rukus
PSE Evolve 35
Elite Emerge
PSE Chaos
Mission Switch
Mathews Traverse
Hoyt RX3
PSE Mach 1
Mathews Halon X Comp
Hoyt Carbon Spyder 34
Bowtech Reckoning 35
Bowtech Reckoning 35 LH
Hoyt RX-7 Ultra

My advice is to know your budget for the whole package (bow, rest, sight, stabilizer, quiver, arrows, broadheads, release, case, and maybe a target) and shoot everything in your budget.

This year I went in knowing I would buy the Mathews V3X 33, because it was like an upgraded Traverse. Shot everything aluminum and had decided on a Bowtech SR350 (Hoyt Ventum Pro 33 out off stock). My wife called and said "make sure it's the right one, I'm tired of all the trading/selling."
So the $400 higher carbon Hoyt RX-7 Ultra was an option now (and still in budget after selling off some target stuff). I'm not sure if it was $400 better, but I did prefer it over the Bowtech. I'm past the honeymoon phase with the Hoyt and I still have no desire for something else.

As far as companies go and customer service combined with dealer support, Mathews is hard to beat.



phorizt
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Pinche Guero said:

Don't sleep on Bowtech and PSE. Like others have said, go shoot some and see what you like. I'm currently shooting a Bowtech solution and really like it.
I shoot the same bow. I'm always tinkering, tweaking my setup, arrows, broadheads etc and like Bowtech's deadlock technology so I can easily tune it after each change.

I will say that I hate the skeletonized Bowtech grip so I made some mammoth ivory inserts for it and it feels great now.
BCO07
How long do you want to ignore this user?
killbutchereat said:

Mathews is way better than Hoyt. Just ask me, I shoot a Mathews. Please do not consult Hoyt Ag for his opinions.


I think he's shooting a Mathews now
Pinche Guero
How long do you want to ignore this user?
phorizt said:

Pinche Guero said:

Don't sleep on Bowtech and PSE. Like others have said, go shoot some and see what you like. I'm currently shooting a Bowtech solution and really like it.
I shoot the same bow. I'm always tinkering, tweaking my setup, arrows, broadheads etc and like Bowtech's deadlock technology so I can easily tune it after each change.

I will say that I hate the skeletonized Bowtech grip so I made some mammoth ivory inserts for it and it feels great now.
I ghetto rigged my grip with some bat tape to make it bigger
JSKolache
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ford vs Chevy
tandy miller
How long do you want to ignore this user?
JSKolache said:

Ford vs Chevy


This.

I can't stand the way a Hoyt shoots, but I've also shot a Mathews for 20 years. As others said, shoot both and sign up for which ever cult's bow feels the best to YOU
Zheinsohn
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I plan on going to shoot some. The ford vs Chevy thing makes sense. Like y'all said in todays world all new bows are going to shoot well
TDub5
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Go in with a budget in mind - if you aren't prepared to drop two grand on a bow and accessories then do not pick up the new models. I have had multiple friends get in trouble because of doing so.
Howdy Dammit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TDub5 said:

Go in with a budget in mind - if you aren't prepared to drop two grand on a bow and accessories then do not pick up the new models. I have had multiple friends get in trouble because of doing so.

Everytime I have gotten a new bow, I just go on eBay and get last years model Mathews for half price. Paid $585 for my triax in 2018.
TDub5
How long do you want to ignore this user?
That's the smart way to do it. Red III had a screaming deal on a Triax the other day that was absolutely loaded when it comes to accessories.
Woods Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Great question!

I'm going ot give my opinion even though it's not any better than anyone else who has tried at least both of them.

I started with a used Hoyt.. Maxxis 33 or 32 or something like that.
That ****ing bow was a tack driving, flat shooting, beast of a bow. At 50 yards (as far as I shot at the time) it was slinging flat arrows and I was consistently grouping them on top of each other and splitting arrows. Granted at the time I was shooting 50 arrows a day, every day... You can say I get obsessed with things.

Long story short, I blew that bow up and needed a new bow. I went to my local bow shop and shot every bow they had.

Now, at the time all of my bow hunting friends show Mathews, and I worked out with them every morning... so every ****ing morning I had 8 *******s telling me i might as well hump Cam Hanes, etc etc..

Back to the story - The triax was just released and everyone was drooling over it. I went and shot every bow, and at 15 yards on the trial range, I started to see the hoyt was a little less "gentle" or "smooth" or whatever in the hand, and that Triax shot like butter... "Oh it's dead in the hand!"

Whatever, I bought the Triax and it's a great bow. But at 40 yards it starts to throw an arc on a shot like someone granny shooting a freethrow... I shoot out to 70 yards now with it and it's an granny shot like you wouldn't believe. I'm pulling 70#s just as i did with the Hoyt.

If I can ever talk my wife into shooting (she loves shooting guns and the outdoors in general, so there is hope) then I'm going to get the newest hoyt the next day and giving her this Triax, but until this, this thing will do.
Goodest Poster
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Tiers:

Mathews, Hoyt

Blowtech, PSA, Elite

Its all about feel. You need to go pull several. I personally dont like the draw motion of the Hoyt. V3x here.
Always the most goodest
Zheinsohn
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Well guys it all happened faster than I thought it would but found a deal that was too good to pass up on and am currently waiting the arrival of my new Matthews V3 31. Looking forwards to it!
Howdy Dammit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Zheinsohn said:

Well guys it all happened faster than I thought it would but found a deal that was too good to pass up on and am currently waiting the arrival of my new Matthews V3 31. Looking forwards to it!

Congrats
tandy miller
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Zheinsohn said:

Well guys it all happened faster than I thought it would but found a deal that was too good to pass up on and am currently waiting the arrival of my new Matthews V3 31. Looking forwards to it!


Did you find a v3 still on the shelf somewhere?
Zheinsohn
How long do you want to ignore this user?
No, new to me I should've said. Bow was sighted in and hunted with one time.
Being shipped to me
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.