Outdoors
Sponsored by

P365XL holster options?

4,817 Views | 21 Replies | Last: 5 yr ago by Hoyt Ag
tfunk02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I've never been a EDC person before. What does the Outdoors board recommend for a holster?
I'm all about comfort, so what is the most comfortable?

I've been looking at these.
https://aliengearholsters.com/holsters/sig-p365xl.html
gibberish
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Phlster Pro Series will serve you well.

Daddy-O5
How long do you want to ignore this user?
VanGuard 2 Kit for Sig P365 and P365XL - Raven Concealment Systems (rcsgear.com)

Highly recommend. I've tried a couple, this stuck.

Edit: They've got an "upgraded" one now with the claw that's supposed to keep the grip closer to you, no experience with that but I've got the original and it's pretty invisible already.
EMY92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I've used Alien Gear for 5 or 6 years now with my Shield. I would happily buy another.
cahoots
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Eclipse makes a great IWB that I use with my XL. Love it.

https://eclipseholsters.com
tfunk02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm going to try out that VanGuard one first. The price is great and I'm a minimalist for size. Phlster might get a look if the VanGuard doesn't work for me. Thanks for all of the help. They all look like good choices.
BearJew13
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Haven't been able to find one yet that can accommodate a laser/light and RMR...
dr_boogs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Check out CompTac infidel.
96AustinAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
No to Alien Gear. There are better choices available.
digging tunnels
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I like my Vedder Light Tuck IWB holster. the height and the cant can be adjusted. I carry both at appendix and 3 o'clock. price is pretty steep but worth it imo
Baba
How long do you want to ignore this user?

I remember you from another board.

You finish pharmacy school? (think that was you, if it wasn't my apologies)
96AustinAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
tfunk, it can depend on how you plan to carry it. For appendix carry/AIWB, the list of companies that make good holsters for that is more limited, but there is plenty available. There are a few more options for IWB hip or behind-the-hip carry. Do you know how you want to try to carry?

Either way, it is imperative to get something with an adjustable ride height. You REALLY need to be able to get the grip high enough above the belt for you to quickly get your fingers all the way around the grip while the gun is fully in the holster.

- KR Training instructor

Edit: Raven gear is definitely in the top tier. Phlster, JW Custom Kydex, Dark Star Gear are others.
tfunk02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm not 100% sure since I've never had one, but I think I'd like behind the hip the most. I am a minimalist, so the smallest one that doesn't feel bad would be my top choice.
TSJ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Red River Tactical made a holster for my 365xl. Prices are good but the wait was about 5 weeks.

https://rrtholsters.com/2020/



dr_boogs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If you haven't carried daily, you're just going to have to try a number of them and see what is most comfortable to you. It depends on body type, clothing choices, and as many have said how you are going to carry. Hasn't been said here but is typically said on holster threads - start with a good belt. Not a dress belt that you'd buy at a clothing store, a dedicated carry belt that can double as a regular belt. This will make any holster/set up so much more comfortable. It's a total game changer.

A lot of people carry exclusively OWB with a concealment garment. That's going to be the most comfortable. Check out Comp-Tac Warrior. Made in Houston area, great company, great service, not cheap. IWB introduces some degree of discomfort, but it can be anything from minimal/un-noticeable for 8 hours at a time, to "holy moly this thing is digging in my side I've got to get it off me". Comp-tac Infidel is my choice. As an instructor told me years ago, CCW should be comforting, not entirely comfortable. Most of us have a box of gently used holsters that didn't make the cut for whatever reason. I gave 4 of mine to KR training the last time I was there because they were for a lefty and had been sitting in a box for years.

Last comment based off of several years of instruction and practice since you're just getting in to daily carry. Many people want to carry subcompacts and pocket guns because they are convenient, small, more comfortable and easier to conceal. I get it, and I started here. They are also difficult to shoot and make hits with under pressure. If you only shoot occasionally (these days ammo is scarce and $$) and you just punch paper with no time constraints or movement, you really don't have a full appreciation of how difficult it is to make hits under pressure. Get a shot timer, practice using some drills under pressure, or better yet go take a lesson with KR or other highly reputable trainer and you'll ditch that 3 inch subcompact the day after your class is over. Carry the largest pistol you can comfortably carry and conceal for however many hours a day you plan to carry. The P365 XL would be the smallest I'd recommend if at all possible, it's a great choice. Practice your concealment draw regularly with an unloaded gun. Lots of dry-fire exercises you can do as well. Good luck!

ETA: I'd be cautious on that Vanguard holster if you're just getting started. Yes, it is minimalist and is better than sticking it in your waistband (that's right from their website lol), but you want to carry with a round in the chamber. Starting out you should select a Kydex option that completely shrouds the barrel, trigger, trigger guard and only leaves the grip exposed. One thing that you will deal with if you carry regularly is lint build-up on your weapon. A fully enclosed weapon will not gather as much of that as one that is carried with that Vanguard.

***Would be interested in what 96AustinAg has to say about that Vanguard since he/she's a KR instructor. Karl occasionally stops by and chimes in on these threads too.
jwright4288
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I've tried a lot of different holsters and settled on stealth gear for everything IWB and Wright leather works for anything OWB.

https://stealthgearusa.com/sig-sauer-p365-mini-ventcore-holster/

I use this exact holster for my 365 (and other guns) and this thing is incredibly comfort for all day wear even when outside in the Texas heat for hours due to how well it vents.

*edit - they are pricy but they are 100% but they also accept returns in case you try it and hate it. They also often have promo codes/sales for 15+ percent off to get the cost down a bit.

**edit 2 - SAVE15 for 15% off
BrokeAssAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I have the Vedder pocket holster and like it.

https://www.vedderholsters.com/pocket-locker-holster/?gclid=CjwKCAiA_9r_BRBZEiwAHZ_v1-hXc31-b4L7-mJnjRoxY5Tf4Q3ST8Jb0Tu-r2g5cq4hzo_FOFmwlRoCfQoQAvD_BwE
96AustinAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
dr_boogs said:

If you haven't carried daily, you're just going to have to try a number of them and see what is most comfortable to you. It depends on body type, clothing choices, and as many have said how you are going to carry. Hasn't been said here but is typically said on holster threads - start with a good belt. Not a dress belt that you'd buy at a clothing store, a dedicated carry belt that can double as a regular belt. This will make any holster/set up so much more comfortable. It's a total game changer.

A lot of people carry exclusively OWB with a concealment garment. That's going to be the most comfortable. Check out Comp-Tac Warrior. Made in Houston area, great company, great service, not cheap. IWB introduces some degree of discomfort, but it can be anything from minimal/un-noticeable for 8 hours at a time, to "holy moly this thing is digging in my side I've got to get it off me". Comp-tac Infidel is my choice. As an instructor told me years ago, CCW should be comforting, not entirely comfortable. Most of us have a box of gently used holsters that didn't make the cut for whatever reason. I gave 4 of mine to KR training the last time I was there because they were for a lefty and had been sitting in a box for years.

Last comment based off of several years of instruction and practice since you're just getting in to daily carry. Many people want to carry subcompacts and pocket guns because they are convenient, small, more comfortable and easier to conceal. I get it, and I started here. They are also difficult to shoot and make hits with under pressure. If you only shoot occasionally (these days ammo is scarce and $$) and you just punch paper with no time constraints or movement, you really don't have a full appreciation of how difficult it is to make hits under pressure. Get a shot timer, practice using some drills under pressure, or better yet go take a lesson with KR or other highly reputable trainer and you'll ditch that 3 inch subcompact the day after your class is over. Carry the largest pistol you can comfortably carry and conceal for however many hours a day you plan to carry. The P365 XL would be the smallest I'd recommend if at all possible, it's a great choice. Practice your concealment draw regularly with an unloaded gun. Lots of dry-fire exercises you can do as well. Good luck!

ETA: I'd be cautious on that Vanguard holster if you're just getting started. Yes, it is minimalist and is better than sticking it in your waistband (that's right from their website lol), but you want to carry with a round in the chamber. Starting out you should select a Kydex option that completely shrouds the barrel, trigger, trigger guard and only leaves the grip exposed. One thing that you will deal with if you carry regularly is lint build-up on your weapon. A fully enclosed weapon will not gather as much of that as one that is carried with that Vanguard.

***Would be interested in what 96AustinAg has to say about that Vanguard since he/she's a KR instructor. Karl occasionally stops by and chimes in on these threads too.
I would definitely recommend more holster coverage than the Vanguard, especially for someone new to carrying. Keep the gun clean, keep your clothes clean (your pistol SHOULD BE well lubricated), and at least for classes etc. you need the ability to easily and safely reholster. Good comments above, Doc.

-Dave Reichek
mts6175
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Stealthgear is by far the most comfortable holster IMO.
Daddy-O5
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I understand both yours and Dr. Boogs points about the Vanguard. Two things really make sense to me:
  • Potential lint building up + ensuring the gun remains clean/well lubricated
  • Ability to unholster/reholster when needed

That said, you both mention experience when considering a minimalist holster like the Vanguard. what is it that you gain with experience to make it a safer/more plausible option?

I can (and do) ensure that it's well maintained, and carrying it only a daily basis rarely requires reholstering.

Just for the record, I am 100% differing to the experts on this. I'm not questioning the logic, just trying to better understand.

ashleyschaeffer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I went with these guys, hybrid with a 3/4 Kydex shell that covers the trigger guard:

Specifically the Protos-M.

Black Arch Holster

Also have the Vedder pocket holster for the P365 SAS.
Bob Lee
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I've been through 10 or 12 holsters over the years.

Here's what I've landed on:
IWB concealed: comforttac belly band

OWB open/BBQ holster: Tucker Gunleather HF1 (If you're going to wear your pistol on your belt, I recommend you get their gun belt or something similar). I've not found a leather belt that's comparable, but there are some built around metal inserts that hold up nicely and are cheaper.
Hoyt Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I had 3 holsters made last year by Wright bros holsters and they are comfy as hell.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.