Outdoors
Sponsored by

Mystery Shotgun

5,920 Views | 13 Replies | Last: 10 yr ago by JR69
HookThis
How long do you want to ignore this user?
https://www.gunsamerica.com//968806044/Mystery-Shotgun-Can-You-Identify-I.htm?wl=1

Interesting A-5ish looking shotgun that has thus far defied indentification



Finn Maccumhail
How long do you want to ignore this user?
$20,0000????
JR69
How long do you want to ignore this user?
And $750 to ship it!!!
cr06gis
How long do you want to ignore this user?
My LGS is the seller apparently

Gonna try and ask to see it next time im there
Buck Compton
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Looks like a Savage M720 if you ask me. it could still very well be an a-5 or model 11 for that matter. Definitely not worth that much though.

Plenty of custom work on it, including the checkered dust cover and the compensator. Probably the stock as well. Looks smoothed to match a deeper trim on the bottom of the receiver. Looks like the receiver was re-blued, and when it happened, I think they removed the serial number and ID markings as they slimmed it down. Without seeing it disassembled in person, you likely lose all hope of 100% IDing it. Honestly, with all of that work to remove identification characteristics, I'd wager it was first owned by a shady individual.

My guess is that the curious butt stock and all was fitted to an individual owner. No idea why you're slapping that compensator on a 20 gauge though.
Knucklesammich
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I have a US stamped Savage that I inherited from my wife's grandfather. Not sure how he bought I believe he got it from a govt auction unfired and used it to hunt birds all over the world (he was a pan am pilot).

Anyway its rugged, reliable and is 100% all metal and wood. I enjoy pulling it out during dove season and shooting it here and there.
bonfarr
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Is this gun legal to own without a serial number? I guess it could be pretty 1968 or it wouldn't be up for auction.
JR69
How long do you want to ignore this user?
quote:
Looks like a Savage M720 if you ask me. it could still very well be an a-5 or model 11 for that matter. Definitely not worth that much though.

Plenty of custom work on it, including the checkered dust cover and the compensator. Probably the stock as well. Looks smoothed to match a deeper trim on the bottom of the receiver. Looks like the receiver was re-blued, and when it happened, I think they removed the serial number and ID markings as they slimmed it down. Without seeing it disassembled in person, you likely lose all hope of 100% IDing it. Honestly, with all of that work to remove identification characteristics, I'd wager it was first owned by a shady individual.

My guess is that the curious butt stock and all was fitted to an individual owner. No idea why you're slapping that compensator on a 20 gauge though.
The Cutts Compensator was not really what I'd consider "custom", nor was it a compensator like we think of on rifle barrels. They were common on hunting shotguns for the first 6 decades of the 20th Century, much like the Poly Choke, and they had the same function as the Poly Choke - adjustable choke. I don't think they really attenuated recoil, especially on an A5 type gun. My uncle had a Cutts on his 1950s era 12 gauge A5 and it kicked like a mule. They are also LOUD like ported barrels.
Buck Compton
How long do you want to ignore this user?
quote:
quote:
Looks like a Savage M720 if you ask me. it could still very well be an a-5 or model 11 for that matter. Definitely not worth that much though.

Plenty of custom work on it, including the checkered dust cover and the compensator. Probably the stock as well. Looks smoothed to match a deeper trim on the bottom of the receiver. Looks like the receiver was re-blued, and when it happened, I think they removed the serial number and ID markings as they slimmed it down. Without seeing it disassembled in person, you likely lose all hope of 100% IDing it. Honestly, with all of that work to remove identification characteristics, I'd wager it was first owned by a shady individual.

My guess is that the curious butt stock and all was fitted to an individual owner. No idea why you're slapping that compensator on a 20 gauge though.
The Cutts Compensator was not really what I'd consider "custom", nor was it a compensator like we think of on rifle barrels. They were common on hunting shotguns for the first 6 decades of the 20th Century, much like the Poly Choke, and they had the same function as the Poly Choke - adjustable choke. I don't think they really attenuated recoil, especially on an A5 type gun. My uncle had a Cutts on his 1950s era 12 gauge A5 and it kicked like a mule. They are also LOUD like ported barrels.
Fair. My grandpa had an old model 11, and researching them after he passed was the extent of my knowledge. Never shot one. It's still "custom" in that it wasn't a factory option as far as I know. That being said, the rest of the additions still look custom to me unless someone smarter knows of a production a-5 clone with no serial number!
JR69
How long do you want to ignore this user?
quote:
quote:
quote:
Looks like a Savage M720 if you ask me. it could still very well be an a-5 or model 11 for that matter. Definitely not worth that much though.

Plenty of custom work on it, including the checkered dust cover and the compensator. Probably the stock as well. Looks smoothed to match a deeper trim on the bottom of the receiver. Looks like the receiver was re-blued, and when it happened, I think they removed the serial number and ID markings as they slimmed it down. Without seeing it disassembled in person, you likely lose all hope of 100% IDing it. Honestly, with all of that work to remove identification characteristics, I'd wager it was first owned by a shady individual.

My guess is that the curious butt stock and all was fitted to an individual owner. No idea why you're slapping that compensator on a 20 gauge though.
The Cutts Compensator was not really what I'd consider "custom", nor was it a compensator like we think of on rifle barrels. They were common on hunting shotguns for the first 6 decades of the 20th Century, much like the Poly Choke, and they had the same function as the Poly Choke - adjustable choke. I don't think they really attenuated recoil, especially on an A5 type gun. My uncle had a Cutts on his 1950s era 12 gauge A5 and it kicked like a mule. They are also LOUD like ported barrels.
Fair. My grandpa had an old model 11, and researching them after he passed was the extent of my knowledge. Never shot one. It's still "custom" in that it wasn't a factory option as far as I know. That being said, the rest of the additions still look custom to me unless someone smarter knows of a production a-5 clone with no serial number!


Perhaps it depends on the make of the shotgun, but I know for a fact that both Cutts and Poly Choke were a factory option on Browning A5s, Winchester Model 12s and Ithaca Model 37s. They served the same purpose as screw-in chokes do today. In fact, the Cutts could be considered the first screw-in choke as the tapered portion of the Cutts is remove and replace to change the choke - effectively the choke tube and screws in and out. At any rate, no point in arguing over symantics - I was just trying to provide information on the Cutts as they were common on shotguns when I was growing up.
TOM-M
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Did any maker of the a5 design, other that the early Rem 11's, put the safety in front of the trigger?
MasterAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Really looks like a Savage 720 with as was stated above quite a bit of "custom work" done to it. If that isn't it I have NO idea whatsoever.
MasterAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
quote:
Did any maker of the a5 design, other that the early Rem 11's, put the safety in front of the trigger?
Not that I know of and that is confusing me. I tried to look at some of the old Sears guns but couldn't find one with that design either.
AgBQ-00
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Were all the old military guns pump action or was there ever any auto loaders?
JR69
How long do you want to ignore this user?
An interesting article on A5s mentions different licenses granted for the production of John Browning's design. Unfortunately no pictures.

http://www.gundigest.com/gun-collecting-firearm-collecting/those_hammerin_humpbacks


quote:
Thus, the first Browning-designed humpback officially sold in the United States wasn't the Browning Auto-5. It was the Remington Model 11, a near-knockoff of the Auto-5 that was produced under license from Browning from 1911 to 1948. In 1930, another officially licensed Auto-5 clone appeared: the Savage Model 720. Finally, in the 1970s, two other Auto-5 clones were rolled out: the Auto Pointer, made by the Yamamoto Co. of Tokyo, and the Herter's SL-18, made by The Pine Co., also of Japan.
Not mentioned in this article are Franchi and TOZ of Russia, which are mentioned in another article I found, but now can't find it again, who supposedly also made copies of the A5.

Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.