Glenn Greenwald: What is Behind Gen. Mark Milley's Righteous Race Sermon?

3,283 Views | 29 Replies | Last: 4 yr ago by jac4
Fat Black Swan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The American military industrial complex will be turned inward.

https://greenwald.substack.com/p/what-is-behind-gen-mark-milleys-righteous

Quote:

The overarching ideology of Pentagon officials is larger military budgets and ongoing permanent war posture. Their new war target, explicitly, is domestic "white rage."

For two hundred forty years, American generals have not exactly been defined by adamant public advocacy for left-wing cultural dogma. Yet there appeared to be a great awakening at the Pentagon on Wednesday when Gen. Mark Milley, the highest-ranking military officer in the U.S. as Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, testified at a House hearing. The Chairman vehemently defended the teaching of critical race theory at West Point and, referencing the January 6 Capitol riot, said, "it is important that we train and we understand ... and I want to understand white rage. And I'm white."

In response to conservative criticisms that top military officials should not be weighing in on inflammatory and polarizing cultural debates, liberals were ecstatic to have found such an empathetic, racially aware, and humanitarian general sitting atop the U.S. imperial war machine. Overnight, Gen. Milley became a new hero for U.S. liberalism, a noble military leader which like former FBI Director Robert Mueller before him no patriotic, decent American would question let alone mock. Some prominent liberal commentators warned that conservatives are now anti-military and even seek to defund the Pentagon.

It is, of course, possible that the top brass of the U.S. military has suddenly become supremely enlightened on questions of racial strife and racial identity in the U.S., and thus genuinely embraced theories that, until very recently, were the exclusive province of left-wing scholars at elite academic institutions. Given that all U.S. wars in the post-World War II era have been directed at predominantly non-white countries, which like all wars required a sustained demonization campaign of those enemy populations, having top Pentagon officials become leading anti-racism warriors would be quite a remarkable transformation indeed. But stranger things have happened, I suppose.

But perhaps there is another explanation other than righteous, earnest transformation as to why the top U.S. General has suddenly expressed such keen interest in studying and exploring "white rage". Note that Gen. Milley's justification for the military's sudden immersion in the study of modern race theories is the January 6 Capitol riot which, in the lexicon of the U.S. security state and American liberalism, is called The Insurrection. When explaining why it is so vital to study "white rage," Gen. Milley argued:

"What is it that caused thousands of people to assault this building and try to overturn the Constitution of the United States of America? What caused that? I want to find that out. I want to maintain an open mind here, and I do want to analyze it."

The post-WW2 military posture of the U.S. has been endless war. To enable that, there must always be an existential threat, a new and fresh enemy that can scare a large enough portion of the population with sufficient intensity to make them accept, even plead for, greater military spending, surveillance powers, and continuation of permanent war footing. Starring in that war-justifying role of villain have been the Communists, Al Qaeda, ISIS, Russia, and an assortment of other fleeting foreign threats.

According to the Pentagon, the U.S. intelligence community, and President Joe Biden, none of those is the greatest national security threat to the United States any longer. Instead, they all say explicitly and in unison, the gravest menace to American national security is now domestic in nature. Specifically, it is "domestic extremists" in general and far-right white supremacist groups in particular that now pose the greatest threat to the safety of the homeland and to the people who reside in it.

In other words, to justify the current domestic War on Terror that has already provoked billions more in military spending and intensified domestic surveillance, the Pentagon must ratify the narrative that those they are fighting in order to defend the homeland are white supremacist domestic terrorists. That will not work if white supremacists are small in number or weak and isolated in their organizing capabilities. To serve the war machine's agenda, they must pose a grave, pervasive and systemic threat.

Viewed through that lens, it makes perfect sense that Gen. Milley is spouting the theories and viewpoints that underlie this war framework and which depicts white supremacy and "white rage" as a foundational threat to the American homeland. A new domestic War on Terror against white supremacists and right-wing extremists is far more justifiable if, as Gen. Milley strongly suggested, it was "white rage" that fueled an armed insurrection that, in the words of President Biden, is the greatest assault on American democracy since the Civil War.
DrEvazanPhD
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Never give up your guns.
stetson
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Apparently, he is more interested in understanding a mostly peaceful protest that occurred on one day than understanding an entire summer of rioting, looting, fires and murders. His is a political position and he is a lap dog of the administration.
MaxPower
How long do you want to ignore this user?
6 months ago I'd have been proud for any of my boys to enlist. I'd try to dissuade them now. I imagine many other families feel similarly.
Sid Farkas
How long do you want to ignore this user?
none of the 'rage' i see on the internet and TV is coming from white people.

what are they talking about?
rocky the dog
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Elections are when people find out what politicians stand for, and politicians find out what people will fall for.
sanangelo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
My family patriarchs are 3 generations of service in the military - 2 USAF. 2 of the 3 gave their lives for this country. My son's generation broke that tradition and I'm not in the least bit surprised. The military is about to have a profound recruiting problem if it doesn't already.
San Angelo LIVE!
https://sanangelolive.com/
Sid Farkas
How long do you want to ignore this user?
rocky the dog said:


you my friend have just been added to the government's Official White Rage **** List
Cassius
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I can't say what should happen to any and all members of the US military who share his racist views.
titan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MaxPower said:

6 months ago I'd have been proud for any of my boys to enlist. I'd try to dissuade them now. I imagine many other families feel similarly.
That's a very common reaction actually. Hearing it a lot. It is proper that enlistment go down --- never has there been a more unworthy batch of national politicians and reporters here.

Hopefully this guy and similar do get the full measure of blame for the first few military disasters they will cause. That kind of non-focus on the ball and main point practically guarantees such. Happens every time politics drive military outlook.
FrioAg 00:
Leftist Democrats "have completely overplayed the Racism accusation. Honestly my first reaction when I hear it today is to assume bad intentions by the accuser, not the accused."
Ag In Ok
How long do you want to ignore this user?
So white power is a greater threat to those in the military than suicide or PTSD?
Asking my family, the strong consensus is the VA poses a greater threat than any form of racial or identity pride.
policywonk98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
In case you think this kind of thinking isn't "systemic".

Air Force Academy(my eldest child's top school choice at the moment) professor op-ed in the WashPo last week.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/07/06/military-academies-should-teach-critical-race-theory/

The illogical nature of the opinion and outright mis-information about the founding era in this op-ed is absolutely scary stuff coming from a professor in one of our military academies.

There is absolutely no institution in our country that Progressivism is not touching in profound ways.

Critical Theory in all of its forms is a cancer.

I really dont see how the Republic stays intact without a revolution to settle the differences.

One example from the opening paragraph. And it just gets worse from there.

Quote:

Joint Chiefs Chairman Gen. Mark A. Milley's recent defense of teaching critical race theory at the U.S. military academies shows that it is not unpatriotic to understand a fuller version of American history, nor does it promote division among our military members.


Critical Race Theory is in no way designed as a framework to give us a fuller version of American history. That's not how understanding or getting at a better understanding of history even works. This opening paragraph is complete CRT propaganda with no basis in truth.

Everyone must understand this. No, it's not unpatriotic for military leaders to have a fuller understanding of history. Nobody that understands the dangers of CRT is suggesting leaders(and teachers and students) not have a fuller understanding of history. CRT does not get you there. That's the problem. When the very foundation of your analytical framework(Critical Theory) is created to tear down one philosophical framework to replace it with another. That's what will happen with every iteration of that analytical framework.

NormanAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Doesn't the entire premise of CRT boil down to white people must atone for the sins of the nation's forefathers? Can't I just say I'm sorry and I promise not to commit the same sins?

And what about the white people who immigrated to this country LONG after it was founded? If a white person can prove their ancestors came here in the late 1800s/early 1900s (includes my wife's ancestors on her fathers\'s side), shouldn't they win a get out of jail free card?

In the long history of mankind on this planet cultures and societies have progressed tremendously - from barbarians to civilized people. Sadly, there are countless cultures in the world that are still basically uncivilized - and that includes many African nations.

Our American society/culture is far from perfect, but thanks to our founders - WHO PUT US ON THE RIGHT PATH (in spite of their many problems/biases/etc) we have progressed to become one of the few truly civilized societies in the world. And arguably, the most civilized and enlightened country in the world. A country that is generally admired and respected (except by our enemies). So much so that there are millions of people wiling to risk their and their family's lives to enter our country illegally.

Our politicians, our educators, our media, etc, etc should be CELEBRATING our country, while at the same time striving to make it even better for EVERYONE. (Note: that's the outlook I was taught growing up in the 50's and 60's.)

We should live by the familiar motto: Never Backwards-Always Forward.!
Quote:

The motto of "never backward, always forward, always" encourages us to shut the door on our past and focus on our futures. It asks us to let go of that which we cannot control and focus on bettering ourselves, our circumstances, and our communities a little bit every day.
We must LEARN from our past, but we CANNOT CONTROL IT. It's history - warts and all - and cannot be changed. Focus on the here and now and MAKING IT BETTER!

CRT is looking backward and dividing our country. It is the OPPOSITE of "focusing on bettering ourselves, our circumstances, and our communities, a little bit every day". CRT is a sure fire recipe for disaster, focusing on our past (LONG SINCE past) failures while dividing our country and doing NOTHING that can better "ourselves, our circumstances, and our communities". How supposedly intelligent people in power in this country cannot see these very basic facts astounds me to no end.

/old fart rant over
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sid Farkas said:

none of the 'rage' i see on the internet and TV is coming from white people.

what are they talking about?
It's gaslighting straight out of 1984 to grease the wheels for subjugation of conservatives.

Pretty blatant and textbook strategy straight out of the history books.
NormanAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Basically yes, but they can and ARE using Jan 6 to make their point. I often see the description "MOSTLY PEACEFUL" on this board. But the "not peaceful" part (and admit it - there WAS some of that) is what the libs/etc are focusing on. Also ,the fact that there were some retired military, and even some active duty military protesters at the Capitol gives Milley all the excuse he needs to make "white supremists" in the military his major priority.

Total BS. Our military needs to focus on China first, then Russia. Not some made up fiction that white supremists are the biggest threat to our country. They aren't even on the map.

Edit: I predict that the military leadership focusing on so called "white supremists" in the military and using that as an excuse to foist CRT on the troops will have the OPPOSITE effect and royally piss off the VAST MAJORITY of them. They are in the military to serve their country, not be accused of something they aren't AND having to put up with marxist CRT brainwashing.

Somehow, I can't shake the fear that that's the plan. Destroy our military from the inside, without firing a shot.
PanzerAggie06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Even merely asking white people of today to apologize is
childishly silly. In regards to slavery, for instance, the notion that people who were never slave owners should have to apologize to people who were never slaves is beyond pointless. Such beliefs aren't based on righting past wrongs they are based a lust for power.
MemphisAg1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
PanzerAggie06 said:

Even merely asking white people of today to apologize is
childishly silly. In regards to slavery, for instance, the notion that people who were never slave owners should have to apologize to people who were never slaves is beyond pointless. Such beliefs aren't based on righting past wrongs they are based a lust for power.
OverSeas AG
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Someone paid him off.

A&M had him on campus.
I despise Marxists... the most repugnant people alive.
titan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
NormanAg said:

Doesn't the entire premise of CRT boil down to white people must atone for the sins of the nation's forefathers? Can't I just say I'm sorry and I promise not to commit the same sins?

And what about the white people who immigrated to this country LONG after it was founded? If a white person can prove their ancestors came here in the late 1800s/early 1900s (includes my wife's ancestors on her fathers\'s side), shouldn't they win a get out of jail free card?

In the long history of mankind on this planet cultures and societies have progressed tremendously - from barbarians to civilized people. Sadly, there are countless cultures in the world that are still basically uncivilized - and that includes many African nations.

Our American society/culture is far from perfect, but thanks to our founders - WHO PUT US ON THE RIGHT PATH (in spite of their many problems/biases/etc) we have progressed to become one of the few truly civilized societies in the world. And arguably, the most civilized and enlightened country in the world. A country that is generally admired and respected (except by our enemies). So much so that there are millions of people wiling to risk their and their family's lives to enter our country illegally.

Our politicians, our educators, our media, etc, etc should be CELEBRATING our country, while at the same time striving to make it even better for EVERYONE. (Note: that's the outlook I was taught growing up in the 50's and 60's.)

We should live by the familiar motto: Never Backwards-Always Forward.!
Quote:

The motto of "never backward, always forward, always" encourages us to shut the door on our past and focus on our futures. It asks us to let go of that which we cannot control and focus on bettering ourselves, our circumstances, and our communities a little bit every day.
We must LEARN from our past, but we CANNOT CONTROL IT. It's history - warts and all - and cannot be changed. Focus on the here and now and MAKING IT BETTER!

CRT is looking backward and dividing our country. It is the OPPOSITE of "focusing on bettering ourselves, our circumstances, and our communities, a little bit every day". CRT is a sure fire recipe for disaster, focusing on our past (LONG SINCE past) failures while dividing our country and doing NOTHING that can better "ourselves, our circumstances, and our communities". How supposedly intelligent people in power in this country cannot see these very basic facts astounds me to no end.

/old fart rant over

For insight, look at the gaslighting the Left media-academy fusion is doing now.

Notice they had to go back to something in 2008, that wasn't even a 100 people for their fearsome example.

Could genocide really happen here? Leading scholar says America is on "high alert" (msn.com)

Genocide is actually only a risk if the right loses its fight to never permit removal of the 2nd A and gun bearing.

FrioAg 00:
Leftist Democrats "have completely overplayed the Racism accusation. Honestly my first reaction when I hear it today is to assume bad intentions by the accuser, not the accused."
panhandlefarmer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

Sid Farkas said:

none of the 'rage' i see on the internet and TV is coming from white people.

what are they talking about?
It's gaslighting straight out of 1984 to grease the wheels for subjugation of conservatives.

Pretty blatant and textbook strategy straight out of the history books.


Their goal is to make up a domestic enemy and an argument for defeating said enemy, so they can suspend the Insurrection Act of 1807 and the Posse Comitatus Act of 1878.
titan
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Then declare what ratified in June 1788 as suspended and renounced as well.
FrioAg 00:
Leftist Democrats "have completely overplayed the Racism accusation. Honestly my first reaction when I hear it today is to assume bad intentions by the accuser, not the accused."
FCBlitz
How long do you want to ignore this user?
That whole article is full of BS

In simple terms it is an improved narrative from the Obama days. Obama forced a narrative thst the new terror threat would home grown. Fueled by angry, white vets. For Obama 2.0, the narrative was refined to extreme patriotism.

Screw the Gen, the actual bad guys operating the country and all of the sheep that believe this non sense at face value.
Ag87H2O
How long do you want to ignore this user?
panhandlefarmer said:

YouBet said:

Sid Farkas said:

none of the 'rage' i see on the internet and TV is coming from white people.

what are they talking about?
It's gaslighting straight out of 1984 to grease the wheels for subjugation of conservatives.

Pretty blatant and textbook strategy straight out of the history books.


Their goal is to make up a domestic enemy and an argument for defeating said enemy, so they can suspend the Insurrection Act of 1807 and the Posse Comitatus Act of 1878.
Spot on. In a sane world domestic terrorism, to the extent it exists, no matter the participants, should be handled by the FBI and Justice Department (and I know how corrupt they've become). The military's job is not to take actions against American citizens.

This is more intentional leftist overreach and a huge red flag. Scary stuff.
mjschiller
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Milley is a supporter of communist china.
geoag58
How long do you want to ignore this user?
NormanAg said:

Basically yes, but they can and ARE using Jan 6 to make their point. I often see the description "MOSTLY PEACEFUL" on this board. But the "not peaceful" part (and admit it - there WAS some of that) is what the libs/etc are focusing on. Also ,the fact that there were some retired military, and even some active duty military protesters at the Capitol gives Milley all the excuse he needs to make "white supremists" in the military his major priority.

Total BS. Our military needs to focus on China first, then Russia. Not some made up fiction that white supremists are the biggest threat to our country. They aren't even on the map.

Edit: I predict that the military leadership focusing on so called "white supremists" in the military and using that as an excuse to foist CRT on the troops will have the OPPOSITE effect and royally piss off the VAST MAJORITY of them. They are in the military to serve their country, not be accused of something they aren't AND having to put up with marxist CRT brainwashing.

Somehow, I can't shake the fear that that's the plan. Destroy our military from the inside, without firing a shot.


What other reason for this crap could there be but a marxist takedown of our country. I have seen many on here defend milley as a great soldier. Well the soviet union had some great soldiers but it doen't mean they weren't marxists. I am not say milley is a marxist but he is certainly carrying water for the marxists who are attempting to take over our country.
Fight against the dictatorship of the federal bureaucracy!
zoneag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sanangelo said:

My family patriarchs are 3 generations of service in the military - 2 USAF. 2 of the 3 gave their lives for this country. My son's generation broke that tradition and I'm not in the least bit surprised. The military is about to have a profound recruiting problem if it doesn't already.


This is exactly what's happening right now in millions of families, my own included. I always expected that my children would likely serve as I did, but it's out of the question now. Something like 1/3 of active duty has a parent that is a veteran. Recruiting is already starting to take a hit, as is retention. There's going to be some real holes in the personnel structure that will take years to fix.
titan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
NormanAg said:

Basically yes, but they can and ARE using Jan 6 to make their point. I often see the description "MOSTLY PEACEFUL" on this board. But the "not peaceful" part (and admit it - there WAS some of that) is what the libs/etc are focusing on. Also ,the fact that there were some retired military, and even some active duty military protesters at the Capitol gives Milley all the excuse he needs to make "white supremists" in the military his major priority.

Total BS. Our military needs to focus on China first, then Russia. Not some made up fiction that white supremists are the biggest threat to our country. They aren't even on the map.

Edit: I predict that the military leadership focusing on so called "white supremists" in the military and using that as an excuse to foist CRT on the troops will have the OPPOSITE effect and royally piss off the VAST MAJORITY of them. They are in the military to serve their country, not be accused of something they aren't AND having to put up with marxist CRT brainwashing.

Somehow, I can't shake the fear that that's the plan. Destroy our military from the inside, without firing a shot.
Actually can always hope if it does piss off the MAJORITY of them, they then go on to do something about it. There is nothing about the present regime that would be missed. Its hard to see anything an anti-Left military couldn't do better.

At the rate we are going, we -- not someone overseas -- will be the Soviet Union of the 21st C. The bad actor that drives most events of regression.
FrioAg 00:
Leftist Democrats "have completely overplayed the Racism accusation. Honestly my first reaction when I hear it today is to assume bad intentions by the accuser, not the accused."
sanangelo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
geoag58 said:




What other reason for this crap could there be but a marxist takedown of our country. I have seen many on here defend milley as a great soldier. Well the soviet union had some great soldiers but it doen't mean they weren't marxists. I am not say milley is a marxist but he is certainly carrying water for the marxists who are attempting to take over our country.
Milley is what the Marxists call a "useful idiot." He has no core beliefs -- or very weak ones-- and is adrift with whatever the popular movement is.
San Angelo LIVE!
https://sanangelolive.com/
MouthBQ98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The top officers in the various branches tend to be professional bureaucrats by and large, as excelling in climbing of bureaucratic hierarchies has gotten them where they are. They want to protect and grow their bureaucracy just like any other government bureaucracy does, and adopting progressive ideology at the top helps achieve this when leftists are in power.

The problem is that is a large deviation from mission and purpose, but it is very politically purposeful on behalf of the left. Subversion and control of institutions is part of leftist revolutionary dogma.
Ag In Ok
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Was milley the one who went against trumps orders to pull out of Syria?
jac4
How long do you want to ignore this user?
zoneag said:

sanangelo said:

My family patriarchs are 3 generations of service in the military - 2 USAF. 2 of the 3 gave their lives for this country. My son's generation broke that tradition and I'm not in the least bit surprised. The military is about to have a profound recruiting problem if it doesn't already.


This is exactly what's happening right now in millions of families, my own included. I always expected that my children would likely serve as I did, but it's out of the question now. Something like 1/3 of active duty has a parent that is a veteran. Recruiting is already starting to take a hit, as is retention. There's going to be some real holes in the personnel structure that will take years to fix.

Or just an opportunity for more leftists to join and ascend to leadership positions.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.