John Francis Donaghy said:
CrackerJackAg said:
I do Smart Home and AV for a living.
I strongly agree with previous post that if you are not going to spend a pretty reasonable amount then just stick with the TV speakers.
I do not think they sound bar is worth getting into until you step up into the Sonos range.
If you are doing a standalone soundbar the Sonos Arc or even the play bars if you can still find them are great.
If you plan to pair a subwoofer with it skip the Sonos. Their subwoofer combination is too expensive.
I like to use the Martin Logan Cadence paired with a reasonable subwoofer. The sound bar is a few hundred dollars more but when paired with a reasonable three to four hundred dollar subwoofer it is vastly superior as a package. The Martin Logan soundbar comes with a wireless subwoofer kit.
Do you have any recommendations for getting clearer dialogue without increasing volume of music/sound effects?
The problem I have is I do most of my tv/movie watching after the kid goes go to bed, and the dialogue using my tv speakers is always difficult to hear, so I turn it up. Then there will be some sound effect or music all of a sudden that will be WAY louder than than dialogue was with booming base and I have to quickly mute or turn it down so it doesn't carry through the whole house and wake anyone up. And I end up making constant 8-10 level volume adjustments up and down the whole time I'm watching anything.
Do you have any recommendations on a setup that will maintain clear discernible dialogue at low volumes without shifting into movie theater mode when there's music/effects?
A good Soundbar will help with this. Sonos warms up the sound my distorting the second harmonics. This sounds nice but some people, including myself, thinks this muddles the vocals a bit.
Still dramatically better than TV speakers.
Companies like Martin Logan (sorry to keep going to that but they are my preferred soundbar) use electrostatic tweeters and they are stunningly accurate but not as warm as a SONOS. It's more accurate sound though.
Last option is to forgo the sound bar, purchase an AVR like a Denon X2800 and place a good center channel under the TV and four speakers in the ceiling. Go as nice as your budget will let you go on the center. Vocals come from it and there is even a vocal enhancer setting in the AVR. Add a sub and you are good to go.
That option can run you in the same kind of price point as a high end soundbar. That's why I typically view soundbar as a last resort option sure to some type of restriction that doesn't allow traditional speakers.
Denon $499-849
Mid Range Speakers $500-800
Subwoofer $300 or so
Cable $99
Sonos Arc - $799
Sonos Arc with Subwoofer $1500
Martin Logan Cadence with Subwoofer $1449
https://www.martinlogan.com/en/product/cadence