Home Improvement
Sponsored by

Home Library Build (Pic Heavy)

27,344 Views | 164 Replies | Last: 1 yr ago by BenTheGoodAg
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wanted to post a build thread for a library I'm planning to build-out in our under-stairs closet.

Long story short, we've got way too many books and not enough space. With our lifestyle, that's going to continue. So I suggested a conversion of the closet underneath our stairs, which is very under-utilized space. All-in, I think we can add space for 2500 books, and it can serve as an expanded pantry for future buyers, due to proximity to the kitchen.



So, the twist to this space is that is pretty narrow. I decided to take in the space between the drywall and incorporate the studs into the shelving design. This adds a lot of vertical, but makes it possible to put shelves on both sides of the closet. In my head, I expected these shelves to be painted, but will end up being stained, so a lot of detail work. This image is a bit fisheye, but gives an idea of expected floorspace. We expect to add a couple of beanbags in the back with a reading light.



I enjoy carpentry, and continue to learn, but will need to pick up a few skills on this project. I just got a nice cabinet saw, so a good chance to put it to work.



I've got my idea designed in Fusion, and accounted for the studs and tolerances. I came up with this trim design to help visually account for high number of vertical lines, and it matches some of the trim in our house. I'll plan to tile the floor with the same tile that's in the rest of our house. Most of the shelves will be adjustable, with tracks, but a couple of layers will be fixed to help keep the individual bays true, due to the height.



And finally, I printed a model of it. I find this really handed to look it over and make adjustments. This is my 3rd iteration of this print, with some tweaks in between prints.



Hope this will be a fun project to follow and leverage expertise on here for.

Happy 4th, yall!
tgivaughn
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
KUDOS
May I suggest adjustible shelfing, even though once stocked, adjustments are seldom made BUT
easier than planning fixed shelves to suit books of all sizes in advance of stocking?

Some shelving specifications may suggest they can span 36-in or more to save time/materials ....
Ten words or less ... a goal unattainable
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I do plan to use some embedded tracks for adjustable shelving to match other built-ins in the house, but will probably fix the 3rd and 6th shelves.

Wish I could span further, but the vertical columns are set by the studs.
sts7049
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
for my OCD's sake, can you make the tallest column also have the double-size space at the top like all the others?
bco2003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Following!
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Haha! I understand. Just a way for my wife to see what one would look like at that elevation and compare. They'll be removable, so either all or none will have them. I'll make enough for all of them up front.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Dude, I'm super jealous of the 3d printer.
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
They're handy. Had mine about 6 months and really like what I can do with it.
Rattler12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Any particular reason for 7 columns ?

Duh never mind .....i just read the part about utilizing the 3 1/2 inch depth between the studs
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Question of the day - Staining. Do I stain pre-install? Post-install? I've seen both ways.

Basically, each vertical bay will end up being a box, similar to a cabinet box. Once the boxes are installed, come back with trim on the face.

I was leaning towards spraying stain and poly for the boxes and removable shelves pre-install. Maybe staining the trim pre-install, but applying poly on the trim once it is installed.
agz win
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Any lighting to read the book spine titles?
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
agz win said:

Any lighting to read the book spine titles?
I've gone back and forth on a couple of methods. Personally, I think some kind of embedded strip lighting would be badass, but between the shelves being adjustable, and just the sheer amount of ribbon lighting that might take, I'm probably not going that route.

Currently thinking of using 4 can lights with adjustable eyeballs, and maybe a 5th down light in the middle. I'm planning a couple of mini can lights (2") close the back for reading.

Ideas welcome, though.
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Some updates from this weekend:

- Removed the ceiling drywall. I was originally thinking about keeping, but decided it'd be easier to a lot of things (electrical tweaks, installation of the shelves, lighting install, etc).

- Relocated electrical in the walls to better locations. There were 3 outlets and one light box throughout the walls. I was able to relocate the outlets, but the light box isn't going anywhere. I'll have to make a portion of that shelf a little shallower.


- Replaced two studs that were badly warped. One had been nearly cut through and the original installer had installed some bracing that would take up shelf space. I used an oscillating tool to cut off the drywall off of the old studs. The backside of this wall is a floor to ceiling built-in set of cabinets, so boogering up the drywall wasn't a big deal. Add a couple of extra screws from the backside cabinet to the new studs.


- I've had a nice Shop Fox table saw base, but with the new saw, needed the extension. Got that in and installed. I'm going to have to tweak the outfeed table since the saw sits a little taller, and the adjustable feet weren't tall enough. I can shim it for this project, but that's another project for another day.

- Made some tweaks to the design to account for actual conditions. First - moving the back shelf up one bay, which adds another row. I can make these back shelves much deeper, and it actually adds shelf space. Second - planning to taper the top corner of the closet instead of keeping it to a point. Third - added some lighting just for the visual. Thinking six adjustable can lights, plus the reading light. Overall, I think this looks much better, personally.


Next step is to buy the plywood and S2S Oak. They didn't have what I needed in stock but will this week.

ETA - I also fixed the shelves, just for sts7049's sake

File5
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Looking good! Your kids are going to absolutely love this.

Are the lights going to point perpendicular to the drywall in the ceiling, or is that fixed by being adjustable?

What about just painting the stair ceiling and running conduit for electrical? Lights could be pointed directly down and you'd get a bit more headroom it looks like instead of putting drywall on those big boards on either side of the stairs.
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Thanks!

The adjustable lights should fix that. I need to get my hands on one and see what kind of angle and light pattern it can achieve, but I think it will work.

I'm not worried about the electrical on the ceiling - all of that has been removed. But I'm not so sure about painting the under stairs. The headroom would be nice, but paining the OSB won't look great. Either I'd have to float it, or clad it, or something else. And the center support is offset and also would have to be clad. I think it gets complicated pretty quickly if I want it to match the appearance quality of the shelves I'm going for.
agz win
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Looks good. Unsure you need six cans rather than three closest to the shelving to avoid shadows. Try to avoid any heat producing lighting. Is there adequate air flow?
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Definitely will be using LEDs for heat reduction. I'm not a fan of the built-in lamps though, and it's harder to find products aren't integrated. I'd like to get an actual model to look and the room will be darker with so much wood.

To clarify - there will be shelves on both side. Not sure if that changes your opinion on the count.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The house we bought has a ton of LED can lighting and I swear one in every room is flickering. I thibk I will need to replace them all at some point to keep it all uniform. Something to keep in mind. I'm not a fan of any lighting I cant replace anymore.
frorge
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm guessing with the addition of the reading light and chairs you're wanting to read in this space. Are you planning on adding any ventilation? Even being an interior enclosed room, I imagine it will get mildly warm in the summer months.
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yup!
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
That's a good point. I hadn't thought about it.
The Fife
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'll second the lighting possibly being a bit much. You may want to get your hands on just 4 of them and temp install just to see what kind of pattern they put out. Gimball lights of course.

I may have missed it but what's the overall size of the space. It seems like an awful lot of shelves for that height and depth, or it could just be the angle the pictures are taken from. Getting decent shots of enclosed areas like that is just about impossible to do.
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
It might be too much. I think I really need to see one in person, especially with a room with so many dark surfaces.

The room is basically 4 (w) x 10 (l) x 9.5 (h). The old shelves allowed about 32" of walkway in front of them. I'm maintaining that with the new design but something like 6-7 times the shelf area., and improving the finishing
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Some updates from this morning:

Started getting tons of materials in:
- Wood-look Tile to match the rest of the house

- Shelving tracks for the adjustable shelves.
- Got several tools in (mostly router bits and setup blocks).
- Went and grabbed most of the wood. I overbought the 4/4 oak for this and a few other projects, Got about 140 board-feet, and probably will use 80-90 to do this project. Thankfully it fit in the space I remaining for my material storage. I was really happy with the lengths they had available. I also got 5 sheets of plywood, but need to get a few more when they get more back in stock.




One of my prints finished this morning. Had to re-print due to the groove being slightly too tight for the plywood. This is a cleat (will be 4 in total) to help me set and secure the top plate at the correct angle. It also helps me measure and set it at the right height on the box. Still amazing how a 3D printer can pop out a custom tool.

PabloSerna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
LED ribbon lighting inside the shelving would be cool?
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Story time, and reason #7,903 a 3D printer has been a game-changer for me.

A young BenTheGoodAg went to an old cabinet-maker's estate sale, and was shocked to learn that he had 4 different table saws! I now understand that cabinet and related work really benefits from multiple machines that are set up for one function, or one cut, or one specific pass, etc. This helps ensure that every cabinet is the same depth, the dados are set the same, etc. Very beneficially for repeatable work.

I was recently given a old table saw, a Craftsman 10" belt-driven contractor saw. It's got a big deck, some good features, but needed some work if I was going to keep using it, and probably a different fence. If you get it set, it works, but it's not great for changing between cuts. My new saw, with the Biesenmeyer style fence is significantly easier to set up for new cuts, and way more adjustable.

I had actually listed the Crafstman for sale, and hadn't gotten a bite yet, when it hit me that I could be using it for this project. I need to add a couple of grooves for the shelf track, and a dado blade on a table saw would be ideal over a router jig, especially given the length of the grooves. I actually have a Dado stack, but no throat insert for this saw. So I pulled up my CAD and got to work.

Overall, the new one was too big for my printer, and needed to be made in two pieces. Compared to the old one:


Gluing together:


Perfect fit. This plate is made with PETG, which is basically what Coca-cola bottles and storage totes and trash cans are made from. There are other plastics that may be better for longer term use, but for this project, it'll work perfect.


Great results:


I'll go back and tweak the insert for close to zero clearance and let it print while I'm working on other things

So bottom line, you can buy throat inserts, but this was A - faster (ready in 7 hours). B - cheaper (probably $2.50 in plastic). C - Repeatable/tweakable (if it didn't fit, just tweak and re-print). D - Totally functional!
TexAg1822
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Following!
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Got my first box completed. Mostly just wanted to make sure all of the steps worked before cutting a bunch of plywood.

I refined my model to make a bunch of measurements on the angles (and to keep learning some Fusion tricks). Not all boxes shown here.



Here's my jig to cut shelf dado's with a router and a 23/32" straight bit. Will dado the bottom and 3rd shelf.



Got the first box assembled and tested in place. This is in the back corner:



But saving best for last - here's how my back corner turned out. I'm frickin' proud of that angled joint. If I can consistently achieve that, I'll be in the money. Nobody will probably ever notice it once the trim is up, but I'll know.




ETA - good wax makes a good tool better.
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Final update for the weekend, and maybe for a little while until I can get more materials in and find the schedule to do more.

- Got the zero clearance dado throat insert set up and really pleased with the results. I have never used a dado blade before this project, but always wanted to. I think I'd find it hard to go back to a router with a straight bit if given the choice.
- There are 13 boxes in total, 6 on each side and one in the back. One of the boxes is going to be a one-off due to the electrical, and the one in the back is also a one-off. Otherwise, I've cut up, dado'd, and grooved all of the plywood for the other 11 boxes. I don't have the lumber for the adjustable shelves, but here's the stack from a day's work:


I am trying to decide between a couple of options for the trim on the front of the fixed middle shelves. I could either cut up individual 1"x2" trim pieces (shown below on the left with red border), or I could cut a 1"x2" groove on the boxes, and install one long piece to help tie the boxes together at the middle (shown below on the right with blue border). Ultimately, there will be a large piece of vertical trim on top of this, so I don't think it's an appearance issue - I just think it might add a nice bit of reinforcement in the middle so they're all fixed together at that elevation. It may not matter, but it's much easier to do now before I start building boxes.
Aggietaco
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Looking great and +1 on the wax. I always wax my saw and sleds before using them, the different is night and day.

That vertical dado and track is going to really bother me inside of your nice ply boxes until you get the shelves filled up with books. I think I would have done pegs, personally. despite the huge time sink for drilling them.
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Haha. I understand. Purely from a looks standpoint, I'd prefer all fixed. Practically, though, it makes a lot of sense to spring for adjustable hardware.

Personally, I don't care for the look of holes. I'm kinda meh on track, but it does match the rest of the built-ins in this house for adjustable shelving, which is probably the biggest driver.

Thanks!
BenTheGoodAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
My schedule got turned around this week, so I managed to make some good progress:

- Grabbed a picture of the angle top jig in action. Worked great:



Decided to cut a dado on the front to tie the boxes together one the fixed shelf front trim:


Got 11 of 13 boxes built. Everything looks nice and straight. All the angles are where I wanted them. Joints look awesome. I did have two pins that I popped in a little too high that I will have to use some wood filler for:


Tested fitment (backs weren't installed). Gives a nice taste of what it will look like:


Wife was very happy with the space and size of the shelves, and it's nice to start seeing it materialize in person.

A couple of things I've been debating:
- Thinking once I have the boxes all set and shimmed and tied into the studs, I may go back with spray foam to fill all the cracks and keep everything snug and even more sound resistant. Also, the stair creak a lot more with the drywall off. I may put some spray foam in all the cracks there as well just to further cut down noise.
- The back of the boxes sit on the bottom plate. I need to attach another stud close to the front of the box. I've always used pressure treated on concrete, but I'm about 80% sure none of the interior bottom plates here are pressure treated (and just not typical for our area). After reading the other thread, I'm a little worried about shrinkage, and may go with a dry stud. Out of habit, though, I really want to stick with pressure treated.
bco2003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Looking good! Thanks for the updates
The Fife
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'd avoid pressure treated because of movement, like you said. They also don't tend to be as straight in my experience.
Aggietaco
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I don't think foam will help with your stair creaking, but you've got plenty of access to tighten things up with some screws, glue, and maybe some reinforcing blocks. Do some searching on stair frame reinforcement and I'll bet you can find some guidance.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.