Is it the 19.2? Is the battery OK? If so, there are a few ways you can go. You can get a bare tool drill like this:
Craftsman C3 19.2 Volt 3/8 Inch Drill Driver Newest Model 315.DD2015 (Bare ToolYou can get the full package and have another battery:
Craftsman C3 19.2-volt 3/8-in. Lithium-ion Drill/driver KitOr, you can punt and go with a totally different brand. If you do that, I'd do 2 things: first, go brushless. Second, get a drill and driver kit. Driving screws with a drill gets old fast, especially after you've driven them with a driver. And if you're going to have a driver, you might as well have the drill from the same maker (same battery, feel, etc.). Currently, my drill (Panasonic -- 15+ years old) and driver (Makita -- 10+ years old) are 2 different brands. It works OK but I'm seriously considering ditching both and buying new.
As far as brands go, well, you'll get everyone's opinion. I'd recommend watching video comparisons of brand shootouts and go with the one that you think suits you. You can't go wrong with most of the big brands: Makita, Dewalt, Milwaukee, etc. I'm partial to Makita but I also have bare tools that use Makita batteries, so I'm somewhat locked into that universe. But I have no complaints.