Business & Investing
Sponsored by

Experian is a joke - Identity Theft Story (in progress)

2,818 Views | 12 Replies | Last: 5 yr ago by YouBet
exp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I was a victim of identify theft for the first time in my life. Someone opened a Best Buy credit card under my name and spent about $2000. The only way I knew about this was Discover card offered free Experian credit report monitoring and alerted me to a new account being opened.

The crazy thing is I ALWAYS keep my credit reports all frozen. My SSN was breached via Blue Cross Blue Shield a couple years ago so I knew I'd be a target for this. So I unfroze my three reports for 10 days when I moved so I could apply for various things, such as utility accounts. This MFer opened the Best Buy account in that tiny window. So either people are CONSTANTLY attempting to open accounts in my name, or this was somebody who knew, like from my old apartments or a realtor or something that saw an application for something.

Anyway, the first thing I did was review my Experian credit summary on their website and saw the new account listed under CBNA. I googled that term to determine it meant Citibank, with whom I do have a card. I called citibank in the middle of the night last night and very quickly had confirmation that no additional consumer credit cards were open for me, but he advised he could be a store branded card which he couldn't necessarily see. So I go download my full report in hopes of seeing additional details, and I see it's listed as CBNA/BBY...another google yields Best Buy credit card.

Perfect, so I call Best Buy credit card department this morning and wait less a minute to get someone. I tell them it was fraudulently opened and they immediately closed the account, apologize profusely, and gave me the number for a dedicated Citibank identify fraud support team that could help me further on Monday. So I haven't yet called them, but I was very satisfied with this interaction.

Then I went to dispute the account with Experian. Their online dispute function is broken and says they are having technical difficulties but I could call during business hours. So I couldn't call last night but I called today. The first thing it does on the phone is condescendingly tell you that disputes can be entered on the website for free....yeah, thanks dudes. Their entire phone system is designed to chew you up and spit you out without ever talking to someone. Pressing 0 doesn't work. If you don't follow their phone tree options they just hang up on you. Trust me, their options are a maze. I eventually figure out the right order of buttons to press and am told I will wait 15 minutes to speak to someone.

After a 15 minute wait, I got somebody on the phone but they said they couldn't process disputes resulting from fraud, I had to talk to a different team. I've since been on hold for THIRTY MINUTES trying to speak to a fraud specialist at Experian. This is fun.

In the interim I've been researching the credit monitoring services they constantly try to upsell you on their website...I MIGHT have considered it but it's quite obvious this company does not stand behind it's services in terms of customer service. How can you make people wait this long in fraud situations? You're the biggest credit bureau in the world.

Anyway, I'm currently on the 1 month trial of their identityworks premium service. There's no option to cancel online, you have to call into this horrendous phone tree to cancel or send snail mail. That alone screams of an organization more interested in easy recurring revenue than actually delivering services.

Anyone else have experience with identity theft or dealing with Experian directly?

I'm honestly so thankful that Discover card offered the free monitoring alerts else I would have no idea this happened. They only monitor Experian though and I would like to monitor all bureaus, as well as my family members. The alerts ARE valuable by themself, but I would rather pay a company that has customer service. I'm pretty sure all the claims of $1million insurance for fraud are essentially uncollectible and an even bigger joke than this phone customer service is.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
My only recent experience are multiple attempts to freeze my credit using their online process but, naturally, it won't let me. I get to the end of the process and it tells me they can't shut mine down online and that I have to call to do it.

Nothing drives me crazier than giving me the option of doing something online and then at the end of it they won't complete the process and force you to call.
62strat
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I monitor mine through USAA. Been pretty happy with it. when I open a card or other account I get a text literally within a minute.
BrazosDog02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I get a text every time any purchase is made or an account it opened. I tried to buy 1000 bucks of guns online out of state and it immediately killed that transaction before starting. Very happy about that even though it's a bit of a pain.
Vernada
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
YouBet said:

My only recent experience are multiple attempts to freeze my credit using their online process but, naturally, it won't let me. I get to the end of the process and it tells me they can't shut mine down online and that I have to call to do it.

Nothing drives me crazier than giving me the option of doing something online and then at the end of it they won't complete the process and force you to call.
same
rathAG05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
LifeLock
Pasquale Liucci
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I dealt with a case earlier this year where some jackass opened three mobile phone accounts (ATT, VZW, T Mobile) in my name and proceeded to buy $15k worth of iPhones on these accounts.

He used my physical address as the mailing address on the ATT account so I was aware of that one in pretty short order. However after that one, he wised up and changed the mailing address so I didn't get account statements on these until they had been forwarded to collections, marked delinquent, and reported to the credit bureaus.

Long story short here's what I learned (I was successful in getting everything off my credit report at the end of the day).

- Open a free account at identity theft.gov. They have a standard form you can fill out to report details of theft along with an affidavit and steps to recovery. It's a really good resource that is provided by the FTC to aid with fraud recovery.

- File a police report immediately if you haven't already. If you have incomplete information that's fine, but bring any documentation you have, including a copy of your identity theft.gov papers. Get a receipt along with officers name and case number.

- Try to get something in writing from Best Buy/Citi that account was fraudulent and opened as result of identity theft. No worries if you can't, but documentation is your friend.

- Print out dispute paperwork for all three major credit agencies. Attach copies of your FTC statement and police report receipt, along with a brief cover letter essentially restating what is on your FTC letter. If you are dealing directly with a company who was defrauded (AT&T in my case) you may also need to prove copies of ID, utilities bills, etc to prove your identity.

- Send certified mail with return receipt to all three major credit bureaus. They will have 30 days from date of receipt to make decision on your credit report. From my experience, with the FTC affidavit and police report, it was all pretty seamless once I sent them my dispute information.

- Keep copies of their eventual letter stating that their investigation resulted in clearing account from your credit record just in case this issue ever reappears later.

Best of luck! ID theft sucks, the guys who perpetrate it are the literal dregs of society.
Good Bull Jones 17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Vernada said:

YouBet said:

My only recent experience are multiple attempts to freeze my credit using their online process but, naturally, it won't let me. I get to the end of the process and it tells me they can't shut mine down online and that I have to call to do it.

Nothing drives me crazier than giving me the option of doing something online and then at the end of it they won't complete the process and force you to call.
same


Same experience here. It shocked me how hard it was to freeze my credit with them. Ended up having to send snail mail. Way easier with Equifax and Transunion. I would never trust a service Experian offers.
IrishTxAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
rathAG05 said:

LifeLock
Waste of money
fourth deck
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This is a pretty decent primer on freezing your information with different credit bureaus.

https://krebsonsecurity.com/2018/09/credit-freezes-are-free-let-the-ice-age-begin/

In summary, you could freeze your file with the big 3 bureaus and still have issues with cell phone carriers because you didn't freeze your file with the NCTUE. It's also a good idea to freeze your files with ChexSystems and Innovis.

And LifeLock is a waste of money.
Bassmaster
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
IrishTxAggie said:

rathAG05 said:

LifeLock
Waste of money
Especially in the OP's scenario. He had his credit frozen but had to unfreeze for a short time.
rathAG05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Why? Honestly curious.
ryanhnc10
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
rathAG05 said:

Why? Honestly curious.


Because the stuff they do is the exact same stuff you can do for yourself
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
rathAG05 said:

Why? Honestly curious.


If you freeze your credit then LifeLock is moot.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.