We went 3-4 years ago when our kids were in elementary and I agree 100% with your review. There's a beating you have to deal with at a huge AI (food, crowds, lack of attention to the details that a nice resort down the beach tends to), but overall it is worth a trip if you have young kids. Beach is amazing, bottomless Makers and Diet (you heard that right snobs) and different areas, each with a different vibe pending on what/who you want to be around. We hung out in the "Key West" area most of the time because it was low-key, but right next door was the "Italian" area which was nuts.