My gut feeling is no without looking at the numbers, but I am open to having my opinion changed.
Games: 2586
At bats: 11,031
Average: .279
On Base: .350
Slugging: .486
OPS: .836
Hits: 2725
Runs: 1582
Runs Batted In: 1587
Home Runs: 435
WAR: 69.8
JAWS: 57.1
wRC+: 118
Awards: 9x All-Star, Rookie of the Year, 3x Gold Glove, 2x Silver Slugger, 7x MVP vote received (highest - 4th, med - 20th)
To me, he's right on the border. Hall of Very Very Good. He had longevity so the counting numbers are solid. He played a hell of a CF for a good chunk of his career. He was probably the best (overall) CF in during his prime. That may be enough though he didn't strike me a hitter to be feared. If you add in his postseason #s then he may be a yes vote. I waiver back and forth.
Games: 2586
At bats: 11,031
Average: .279
On Base: .350
Slugging: .486
OPS: .836
Hits: 2725
Runs: 1582
Runs Batted In: 1587
Home Runs: 435
WAR: 69.8
JAWS: 57.1
wRC+: 118
Awards: 9x All-Star, Rookie of the Year, 3x Gold Glove, 2x Silver Slugger, 7x MVP vote received (highest - 4th, med - 20th)
To me, he's right on the border. Hall of Very Very Good. He had longevity so the counting numbers are solid. He played a hell of a CF for a good chunk of his career. He was probably the best (overall) CF in during his prime. That may be enough though he didn't strike me a hitter to be feared. If you add in his postseason #s then he may be a yes vote. I waiver back and forth.