Corps_Ag12 said:
Chevy tried with the SS and not enough people bought them. It was one trim level with a few different options. Everyone thought it was a Malibu. I think Chevrolet has too many cars in their line up. If they marketed the SS as maybe an impala at different trim levels (like a charger) then it would of been more successful. And maybe done a bit more advertising.
I think a Taurus SHO with an eco boost is a good idea, but it still looks like a regular Taurus. It doesn't seem different until you drive it.
Granted, they don't really advertise either of them at all like Dodge does with the charger base/R-T/396/SRT/Hellcat/Demon
Herein lies the problem. They are only produced in low volume and expensive trim levels and then never advertised. I don't think either company wanted to sell many of either car.
I bought a Flex for my wife with the powertrain from the SHO and it was fun to drive but unreliable. At the end of the day, the SHO still isn't the same as a V8 rwd sedan. It may be quick, but doesn't have the raw feel of a V8 with rwd. A transaxle made of glass made the modification options very limited. I never saw any marketing for the SHO after launch and rarely see any on the road.
The SS was hard to find in a manual and would have been much more attractive if you could have gotten a base model in the high 30s. Price it $5K more than the equivalent Camaro, not $10K for two more doors. They sold well during the GM employee discount period when the pricing was right. The look was also a problem as you mentioned as well as their lack of power train updates after the Camaro and Corvette had already switched the LT1. The marketing was almost non existent and as you mentioned it looked like a Malibu.
Both companies could make a successful rwd V8 sedan if they build one that looks and performs good, isn't priced substantially higher than the equivalent pony car, and they market the hell out of it.
I recently picked up a used 2016 Charger R/T road and track edition for my wife's daily. It already has some of the Chrysler quality bugs, but is a blast to drive. It's the slowest vehicle I own, but it's no less fun than the other two. The 8 speed plus the torque and sound of the 5.7L just give it a real muscle car feel. If Ford had an equivalent car I would have bought it instead. Unfortunately I couldn't find an SS for the price point I needed to keep her at.