AT&T is worse in my experience. I moved to Spectrum a year ago and have been pleased compared to U-verse. If you are truly asking about AT&Ts non-U-verse DSL (if they even offer that anymore) I'd imagine it's worse than U-verse.
I've heard good things about people who have Grande, where it's offered in the city. I'd imagine AT&Ts gigabit fiber offering is good too. Again, limited availability for that service too.