I just finished with the story. I have to say overall, compared to the previous games, I'm pretty disappointed.
The story was completely lackluster and not engaging at all. Balance of Power had a better story than this. The dialog was definitely cringe several times. I appreciate the semi-interaction with your squadron, but it felt hollow. I didnt feel that anything said really expounded upon the story or made me care for them. Honestly, most of the characters were annoying. I also found it funny that were going to chit chat right when we should be loading up. Weird.
I dont like most of the mechanics. I've tried to keep an open mind about it all, but to me, a lot of it just doesn't make sense. It feels overall, like a step backward. It feels like they tried to innovate for the sake of it. I dont like all the extras for the ships. I felt for the most part, it was unnecessary. The point is youre supposed to use your wits and dogfighting ability to out maneuver the enemy. A lot of it just felt out of place. Also the warhead count was really disappointing. X-Wings should be carrying 6 proton torps, not 2 or 3. They are multirole fighters.
The targeting mechanics was wonky and frustrating at times.
Also the amount of fire I have to put into a ship to kill it is just stupid. Maybe it was just story mechanic. Came across times where a lot of the Ties were shielded, which made no sense. I should be able to take out a simple Tie in two or three shots, TIE interceptors in 4 - 6 shots, etc.
Also disappointed there is no button to link your cannons. Same with missiles and torps. No button to cut engines to slow throttle to turn faster, no hyperspace button. I think I could honestly go on.
Overall, I'd give it a C or C+. I havent tried multi-player yet. Ill practice first.
Because I'm Batman!