For the pro bowl just give the winning team double the payout of the losing team, instant competition.
For the No 1 pick they should have reverse playoffs. The last team in each division plays each other just like the regular playoffs, no wild card teams. This year it would be:
AFC
1) West: San Diego (5-11) VS 4) North: Browns (1-15)
2) East: Jets (5-11) VS 3) South: Jacksonville (3-13)
NFC
1) East: Philadelphia (7-9) VS 4) West: San Francisco (2-14)
2: South: Carolina (6-10) VS 3) North: Chicago (3-13)
All the games are played in neutral sites, like bowl games, no home field advantage. But they don't play in NFL stadiums, or college stadiums, they play in rural Texas high school stadiums like Cut and Shoot, Monahans, Snyder, Paris, etc
The better you do, the better your pick, the worse you do, the worse your pick (within the first 8 picks anyway).
And to top it off, Dave South does the play by play for all the games.