Looking for a graphic designer to update a current company logo. Let me know if you can help.
A note on this, more as a public service for anyone thinking about it.EcoZapp.BCS.Air.Roofing said:
- Freelancer , start a contest for $X amount and get like 300 different ideas / amounts of effort.
300 ppl putting forth a tiny amount of effort / creativity on a logo vs. 10,000 hrs. of firm time which might not always originate the best logo.
fig96 said:A note on this, more as a public service for anyone thinking about it.EcoZapp.BCS.Air.Roofing said:
- Freelancer , start a contest for $X amount and get like 300 different ideas / amounts of effort.
300 ppl putting forth a tiny amount of effort / creativity on a logo vs. 10,000 hrs. of firm time which might not always originate the best logo.
I get the sentiment, and on the surface it seems like a good idea. I don't personally like the idea of contests because you've having someone work and not get paid, but on the business side there's also some drawbacks.
To start, most contests don't attract professional designers. You're getting a bunch of students and hobbyists and will often get "borrowed" or recycled work. Do some looking at you'll find lots of examples of folks who found our their logos were stolen, clipart, etc., and the actual ratio of quality submissions can be pretty low.
That being said, I think the quantity over quality argument isn't a great one if you're really trying to develop a identity for your business. If you're looking to truly develop a brand you're not looking for the most ideas, you're looking for the good ones, and if you're not a designer you may not quite know what to ask for.
Rather than having a bunch of designers all spend 30 minutes on your project (which is probably all you're going to get as the only way to make money on these contests is to enter a ton of them), consider the benefit of having one designer actually get to know your business, explore your needs, and look at how your visual identity relates to your overall brand. Your logo is just one part of the bigger picture, and In the long run working with a designer that you can actually have explore ideas with and have productive discussions with is a much better investment IMO.
Just food for thought, sorry for the novel
Most of the folks on those sites are actually not professional designers, not because of their location but because of their skill level. And really, you shouldn't be after a quantity of ideas, you should be after one good one. But you're missing the bigger point: you don't get to have a conversation with a professional who can actually help your business.EcoZapp.BCS.Air.Roofing said:fig96 said:A note on this, more as a public service for anyone thinking about it.EcoZapp.BCS.Air.Roofing said:
- Freelancer , start a contest for $X amount and get like 300 different ideas / amounts of effort.
300 ppl putting forth a tiny amount of effort / creativity on a logo vs. 10,000 hrs. of firm time which might not always originate the best logo.
I get the sentiment, and on the surface it seems like a good idea. I don't personally like the idea of contests because you've having someone work and not get paid, but on the business side there's also some drawbacks.
To start, most contests don't attract professional designers. You're getting a bunch of students and hobbyists and will often get "borrowed" or recycled work. Do some looking at you'll find lots of examples of folks who found our their logos were stolen, clipart, etc., and the actual ratio of quality submissions can be pretty low.
That being said, I think the quantity over quality argument isn't a great one if you're really trying to develop a identity for your business. If you're looking to truly develop a brand you're not looking for the most ideas, you're looking for the good ones, and if you're not a designer you may not quite know what to ask for.
Rather than having a bunch of designers all spend 30 minutes on your project (which is probably all you're going to get as the only way to make money on these contests is to enter a ton of them), consider the benefit of having one designer actually get to know your business, explore your needs, and look at how your visual identity relates to your overall brand. Your logo is just one part of the bigger picture, and In the long run working with a designer that you can actually have explore ideas with and have productive discussions with is a much better investment IMO.
Just food for thought, sorry for the novel
- So , best bet would be to spend ~$300 to $500 to get to hundreds of concepts which might get 90% of the way to a logo, which then can be handed off to a professional firm charging $125+ for 10-50 hours. ( It's not worth the design firms time +1 person does not hold the creative potential of 100's )
We live in a global economy and unless a Start-up has ample supply of funds to burn on a designer, ( logo's and designs don't produce sales; Marketing & Sales Effort produce sales). You can submit a contest tonight before bed an in days you'll have a 100's of logos to choose from, and a few will likely be suitable to carry on further with the designer who made it.
Freelancers that do nothing but design imo are professional designers, just because they are over seas and get paid via competitions, doesn't mean their skill levels are lacking of that of a design firm.
Serious Question... Is this how you got the logo on your website?EcoZapp.BCS.Air.Roofing said:
guys it's 2020, businesses need to pivot fast & smart .
The time spend talking about this, one could of had 1000's different version of Logos to choose from.
1000's of versions of logos' > hours/ weeks/months spent thinking about the perfect design.
People make buying decisions based on Emotions. When you have 1000 different versions to look at one will Emotionally speak louder than the others... or at least look better for X reasons.
If that logic doesn't make sense, there's $100/hr designers that will give 3 professional options.
Gosh, as someone who works in agile development I had no idea businesses needed to pivot quickly. There's also a chance you might not be the only person with business experience here.EcoZapp.BCS.Air.Roofing said:
guys it's 2020, businesses need to pivot fast & smart .
The time spend talking about this, one could of had 1000's different version of Logos to choose from.
1000's of versions of logos' > hours/ weeks/months spent thinking about the perfect design.
People make buying decisions based on Emotions. When you have 1000 different versions to look at one will Emotionally speak louder than the others... or at least look better for X reasons.
If that logic doesn't make sense, there's $100/hr designers that will give 3 professional options.