It does say that, but it also says "But TRAPPIST-1 is so cool that all seven of the bodies are bathed in just the right amount of warmth to hold liquid water", which confuses me, because I thought the Goldilocks zone meant there would be liquid water there.Dr. Watson said:
3 of them are in the Goldilocks zone. I believe most of them are closer to their sun than Mercury is to ours.
I think the solution to that riddle is these planets are so small that they don't have the ability to do so, particularly this close to their star.Quote:
The star is 1/10 the size of the sun and a quarter as warm. Seems like the goldilocks zone must be pretty narrow. I'm surprised all 7 planets are within this zone and are still there. Seems like they would have gravitationally interacted with each other (i.e. planets b&c would be 1.5 times the distance between the Earth & Moon from each other every few days, and these are earth sized planets), flinging some of the lighter ones out of the zone, or out of the system.
I just had the Trappistes Rochefort 10 for the first time last week. Delicious!RAB91 said:
Two earth sized planets within 350,000 miles would definitely interact with each otherSolo Tetherball Champ said:I think the solution to that riddle is these planets are so small that they don't have the ability to do so, particularly this close to their star.Quote:
The star is 1/10 the size of the sun and a quarter as warm. Seems like the goldilocks zone must be pretty narrow. I'm surprised all 7 planets are within this zone and are still there. Seems like they would have gravitationally interacted with each other (i.e. planets b&c would be 1.5 times the distance between the Earth & Moon from each other every few days, and these are earth sized planets), flinging some of the lighter ones out of the zone, or out of the system.
SoulSlaveAG2005 said:
haaaayyy... if you were a planet, named after a beer. Would ya drink yourself???
I know I would, I'd be delicious.
Other than the constant hurricane force winds at the terminus, yeah, it would be habitable.Quote:
The goldielocks zone planets permanently face the red dwarf on one side. Does this mean there would be a strip of habitable area circling the planets in between their cold and hot sides?
AstroAg17 said:
Trillion?
TexAgs91 said:AstroAg17 said:
Trillion?
That's right. Smaller stars last much longer.
oldarmy1 said:
I will put up $1M that there is zero life on any of those planets. Any suckers wanna bet?
It does seem a bit hydrogen poor there (which organic molecules would need). Small star, haven't heard of any gas giants. The planets are rocky? Kind of strange though, hydrogen is the most abundant element.oldarmy1 said:
I will put up $1M that there is zero life on any of those planets. Any suckers wanna bet?
RimshotSoulSlaveAG2005 said:TexAgs91 said:AstroAg17 said:
Trillion?
That's right. Smaller stars last much longer.
I already received the definitive word.Dr. Watson said:oldarmy1 said:
I will put up $1M that there is zero life on any of those planets. Any suckers wanna bet?
When exactly are you expecting a definitive word?