I just got back yesterday. We stayed in Rincon for the majority of the trip in the Puntas area. We just relaxed on the beach and went to the bars in that area. I had a blast, will definitely be going back.
Here is the place we stayed, the Sea Breeze unit:
www.islandmon.com/rentals/.
I would definitely recommend it. Julianne, who owns it, is an extremely cool woman and it just felt like Puerto Rico. It was a little warm at times because there are only window units in the bedrooms, but we never had that big of an issue with it. We found it on VRBO, and got it with 5 people for $110 a night. If you email her, tell her the 5 kids from Texas sent you.
On our last night we stayed in San Juan at the Caribe Hilton. We got it for $120 on Priceline, probably could have gotten it for less. It would have been extremely nice if it wouldn't have been cloudy, but for our purposes it would have been better to stay in Old San Juan.
I'll post pics when I get them uploaded later today.
[This message has been edited by wealeat09 (edited 3/25/2009 10:47a).]