SAR Ag's right. RC was the right guy to take over from Sherrill and he did well... for a while. He did well in a declining SWC against Spike and early Mac editions, but the program was sliding. Fran might have done much better in the same situation.
It was getting pretty bad with RC. Does anyone remember getting beat by U La La (SW La State U at the time)? This is like getting beat by UNT. Of course, I remember a game against UNT at Texas Stadium where they seemed a lot better prepared, with a better game plan, and more motivation. They simply lacked the players, size, and speed, which eventually helped us prevail, despite being outcoached (IMO). To me, that was a turning point. I thought UNT had a better coach (who was eventually fired), if not better talent.
When we went after Fran, I thought it was a great move. He won at every level. He put New Mexico in a bowl for gosh sakes. He took TCU from near futility (much worse than Baylor) to beating USC soundly (this was before LT). He then takes a faltering, flailing, and failing Bama program and returns it to competitiveness overnight. A friend, who won a national championship playing Fran at Pittsburgh State, had nothing but praise for the man.
I wanted this guy. Everyone wanted this guy. Everyone. This was like the Sherrill hire. While SAR might have had reservations, I had none. It was the right move.
Uh, well, maybe it wasn't. At least, in hindsight, maybe it wasn't. However, it seemed a coup by everyone at the time the hire was made.
It was (past) time for RC to step down. Fran looked like a sure bet. I'm sure the situation he inherited was worse than we can imagine. However, at his level and his compensation, he needs to perform. He's had a reasonable time to produce and has not.
From my lazy boy, I think it's time to move on. Of course, I get paid $0 to pontificate from my lazy boy. Dollar Bill gets more and I trust, knows more. His moves in other sports have earned him the benefit of the doubt. Let's give him a chance to make the right decisions.
Of course, I endured the Tom Wilson years and consider virtually anyone better than him (yes, I have low standards). Under Wilson, beating Baylor was an upset.
For those supporting the smug, self-righteous corpse, Joe Pa, I've got a couple of questions...
Do you think he's really the coach and not a figurehead prop with daily embalment ejections in a vain attempt to outlast Bowden to claim the most wins of all time?
Also, do you remember his rather smug, arrogant, self-righteous attacks on our program during the Sherrill and Slocum years (related, of course, to his inability to keep up with in-state rival Sherrill when he coached at Pitt)?
While Joe Pa likes to play saint, there's plenty of sinning in Happy Valley. Sorry, but this is a pet peeve. I don't like the sanctimonious corpse. Hold up other examples, not Joe Pa.
Oh, and does it seem odd that the savior of Alabama struggles in the Big XII and the middle of the road coach from Okie Lite is now one of the best coaches in the might SEC? Could it be that it's easier to win in the SEC than the Big XII? Inquiring minds want to know.