Here is a summary of my visit with Deck Masters last night. As previously mentioned, he was REALLy pushing the cedar. Anything he constructs would be made of the cedar and if you want a different finish/appearance it would simply be clad over the cedar.
What I really want is a hip/ridge structure that looks like it is an extension of the existing structure, and not an add-on. Something not unlike this, but with hardy-clad columns or brick columns:
His estimate for this came out to $11,438. Base price was $7,412 for the structure with these add-ons:
Brick columns - $2,000
Pony wall - $450
Hardi fascia - $376
Hardi clad beam - $900
Permits/Design - $300
Second Choice would be a gable style structure, similar to this but without the "sunburst" structure, we would have a closed gable:
Full price for the gable was $10,412, base price was $6,836
add-ons:
Hardi-clad posts - $300
Pony wall - $450
Hardi fascia - $376
Hardi siding - $1,250
Hardi clad beam - $900
Permits/Design - $300
After I balked at the prices here Blake broke out the "NOW are you willing to consider a shed roof structure?" This was pretty much where he lost us completely. I looked through his shed roof catalog and didn't really see anything I really liked at all, but asked for pricing for comparison purposes.
Their base price for a shed roof at our square footage was $6,260 and would look something like this:
I think that looks like crap, pretty much an afterthought, lean-to add-on that was done at the lowest budget possible, even though its base price was not
that much different than the others.
For a mere $600 more they will add a gable to make the structure look more like this:
his pricing for this structure came out like this:
Base - $6,260
add gable - $600
Pony wall - $400
side walls - $300
Permits/Design - $300
Total = $7,860
Now I've already realized that my initial estimate of $3K to $5K isn't going to cut it unless I'm building it myself, but based on his $6K+ estimate for even the most basic of structure (shed roof) and then almost $8K for what I would consider a compromise at best (the shed w/gable) either I'm completely out of touch with the pricing or he's just way off base with his pricing. I really got the impression that he was just trying to push the basic structure with no add-ons because that is not only the most "economical" for me, but moreso the most "profitable" for him. Looking at the pricing on some of the add-ons on the hip/ridge ($2K for two brick columns) really kinda confirms my suspicions.
OK, that's all my venting for now. I have another guy coming out at 4:30 today to have a look at it, I'll provide an update afterwards.
[This message has been edited by Tree Hugger (edited 2/2/2012 10:10a).]