Texas A&M Football
Sponsored by

ASU/A&M Coaching Staff Comparative Analysis

3,614 Views | 20 Replies | Last: 8 yr ago by SoTxAg
Schrute Farms
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Arizona State and Texas A&M have a lot of incredible similarities. The main coaching staff at each university (HC, OC, DC) have shared uncanny familiarity the last three years. I honestly couldn't be more excited to have ASU as our first opponent this season.

Here are some interesting break downs if you need to kill/waste time:

HEAD COACH

Name................Age...YR Hired....W-L.....Career W%....Bowl W-L...Pres Conf COY....CUSA COY.
Graham (ASU)...50......2012.......28-12... 65% (77-41)......5-2.............2013....................2006
Sumlin (A&M)....50......2012.......28-11....69% (63-28)......4-1.............2012.................2009 & 2011
*COY = Coach of the Year

CUSA Head to Head: 2-1 Sumlin.

Sumlin (UH) competed against Todd Graham (Tulsa) from 2008-2010. After a 70-30 blowout of Tulsa in '08, Sumlin won by 1 in '09 (46-45) and lost by 3 in '10 (25-28). All three years were played against the same HC/DC combo that ASU will have on opening day (Graham/Keith Patterson).

Note: Todd Graham was born in the DFW area (Mesquite) and coached high school football prior to his NCAA coaching career. His most notable stop was Allen HS from 1995-2000. Graham is known to heavily recruit the DFW area, pulling 6 recruits from the region in the last 3 years (none over three stars). ASU is playing at least one football game in Texas for the next three years (Houston, Lubbock, and San Antonio). *Smart* _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

OFFENSIVE COORDINATOR

ASU's Mike Norvell
(Age 33) and A&M's Jake Spavital (Age 29) were members of Graham's coaching staff on the 2008 Tulsa team. Spavital entered the Sumlin/Holgersen pipeline in 2009 while Norvell stayed with Graham through present day. Both OCs employ a spread offense.

Norvell is the highest paid assistant coach in the PAC-12 and 8th highest paid in the country. He was a 2013 Broyles Award nominee (Coordinator of the Year) and has produced a Top 20 scoring offense in each of his three seasons at ASU.

Here is a breakdown of his consistency by end of year NCAA ranking:

Year......Total Offense......Pass Offense......Rush Offense...... Scoring Offense
2012............#24........................#40.....................#25...............................#13
2013............#17........................#23....................#27...............................#8
2014...........#37......................#28................... #56.............................#19

Texas A&M has produced similar numbers during this time but with Johnny:

Year....Total Offense....Pass Offense....Rush Offense.....Scoring Offense
2012...........#2.......................#10......................#14.......................#4...**Kingsbury Finalist for Broyles Award**
2013...........#9.........................#6......................#46........................#6
2014.........#32......................#13....................#78.....................#30

Excluding Johnny, ASU and A&M have comparable offensive numbers that may indicate similar production in 2015.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

DEFENSIVE COORDINATOR

ASU hired a new DC in 2014 (Keith Patterson)
and A&M hired a new DC in 2015 (Chavis). Both defenses have under performed compared to their offenses the last two seasons.

In 2012, ASU boasted the #32 overall defense accompanied by a #2 pass defense ranking. However, in 2013, they slipped to #105 in pass defense, #78 in total defense, and #82 in points allowed. Patterson's first year produced even worse defensive rankings.

Here is a list of each school's rankings side-by-side from the last two seasons. Texas A&M is on the left, ASU on the right.

Year.......Total Def........./Pass Def.........Rush Def.........Points Allowed
2013.......#121/#78.......#106/#105........#119/#43.........#103/#82
2014........#103/#84.......#58/#103.........#112/#51...........#69/#73

Both schools hope for defensive improvement in 2015. Texas A&M's hope is obvious with Chavis. ASU's, however, is more complex. Prior to being hired at ASU, Patterson produced two seasons of forgettable defenses at West Virginia University. In 2012, WVU fielded a #120 overall ranking succeeded by a #93 overall campaign in 2013.

Patterson was hired due to his working relationship with Graham. He was the DC for Graham's 2011 PITT team (featuring Norvell as OC) which featured a Top 35 defense. Additionally, they're life long friends. Patterson and Graham played college football together (East Central U), coached at Allen together, and stayed together in the NCAA with the exception of Patterson's position at WVU. This is the opposite approach of Sumlin by bringing in Chavis.

Player Note: Both Defenses will return a FWAA Freshman All-American. DE Myles Garret for A&M and DJ Calhoun LB for ASU.

Coach Note: Spavital was the WVU QB Coach while Patterson was the DC.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

MISCELLANEOUS

The three year team records are similar but trending in opposite directions:

Year........Texas A&M........ASU
2012........11-2 (#5)............8-5
2013.........9-4 (#18).........10-4 (#21)
2014.........8-5...................10-3 (#12)

Recruiting classes are favored toward A&M (Rivals):

Year........Texas A&M........ASU
2013...............11.................34
2014................6...................21
2015...............10..................20

Both have defeated Duke in a recent Bowl Game:

2013 Chik-Fil-A Bowl..........TAMU 52 - 48 Duke
2014 Sun Bowl....................ASU 36 - 31 Duke
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

That is all. It's just awesome to see two schools, two head coaches, two OCs, and two defenses in similar circumstances square off to set the tone for the season.

End Note: I promise I have a life. This is the sum of staying entertained during a very long, uneventful shift

(Edit to fix formatting)
STX Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sex Panther
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The only thing we have in common with ASU is that we want to have sex with ASU girls
Schrute Farms
How long do you want to ignore this user?
haha...probabaly true
Chickenhawk
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Tl;dr
Craigy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Thanks Farms. I didn't read the part where is stated Graham was an ahole. One of my HS coaching swears that he is.
HUDAT361
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Underrated post
NavyAg92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Good post. Enjoy the football threads. BZ!
Knife_Party
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Thanks for posting. I got as far as the sentence saying there are similarities. Thanks again.
TexagChris17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Nice post
MondayMorningQB
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Football in the football forum.



Nice post OP.
jickyjack1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Very interesting post. Thanks.

Wild stab at the line: A&M -3 1/2
Off_The_Wood
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Very good work OP. I enjoy stuff like this
DTrain
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Tamu_mgm
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
FINALLY some football discussion! Thank you OP.
BillYeoman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
UH vs Tulsa 2009 was great. Tremendous finish.
Schrute Farms
How long do you want to ignore this user?
quote:
Thanks Farms. I didn't read the part where is stated Graham was an ahole. One of my HS coaching swears that he is.
Yeah, that popped up a lot in different articles. He pulled some Lane Kiffen-esque moves with Rice and Pitt by committing for the long haul after one season then suddenly leaving for a better job. Journalists from both fan bases were pretty thorough in detailing his faults. Some pretty funny/cutting tweets by his former players, too.
Schrute Farms
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Glad to see other people enjoy it. It was fun getting lost in football for a moment.
BillYeoman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
quote:
quote:
Thanks Farms. I didn't read the part where is stated Graham was an ahole. One of my HS coaching swears that he is.
Yeah, that popped up a lot in different articles. He pulled some Lane Kiffen-esque moves with Rice and Pitt by committing for the long haul after one season then suddenly leaving for a better job. Journalists from both fan bases were pretty thorough in detailing his faults. Some pretty funny/cutting tweets by his former players, too.


Rice M.O.B. performed a scathing welcome back when Tulsa visited Rice.

I have also heard Graham wasn't allowed to coach HS football in Texas but not sure if there is truth to that.
Womackster
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Nice breakdown
AGSWINAGAIN
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Strength of schedule:

2011-12 A&M: #18 ASU: #47
2012-13 A&M: #2 ASU: # 57
2013-14 A&M: #8 ASU: #12

Forwhatisworth.
SoTxAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Anyone have a clue what time kickoff will be?
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.