Here's my take on this - and a lot of other "Old Army" traditions. Texas A&M has changed immensely since I graduated - there are 5x as many students, there are women, there are women in the Corps (gasp), women's sports teams, there are women's sports teams winning National Championships, the Corps represents 5% of the student body, the Corps is not mandatory, there are fraternities, the campus is more spread out, there is no more G Rollie White Coliseum, no more Guion Hall, there is tailgating before football games, Senior Boots cost 12X what I paid for mine new from Holicks, and so much more.
I don't care for the way some of our traditions are carried out today but I won't go into those because it does not matter. The University is for the current students, not for us Former Students. Some traditions should remain inviolate I believe, but that depends very much on not only the Corps as "Keepers of Tradition", but also on buy-in by the remainder of the student body.
I personally don't like the idea of a panel made up of administrators picking the next Reveille - I'd prefer to see the student body select their own official mascot. A mutt? Maybe - Reveille was a mutt for the first 13 years - but Aggies can do better. The new Rev should be recognizable on television, on Corps trips, at football games, and any other time she is out in public.
Rev II was a Shetland Sheepdog - collie-like but not a collie. I was there when she passed in 1966, having served 14 years as our Official Mascot. Since 1966 Reveille has been a Rough Collie. So what is tradition and what does it dictate? 27 years a non-collie, 8 years (1944 to 1952) there was no Official Mascot, and 48 years a Collie. That's not my decision, nor do I believe it should be the decision of anyone other than the student body.
Most of our traditions don't date back to 1876, so how long does it take for something to be a tradition? When I was a student, freshmen and sophomores didn't work on the Bonfire stack, nor did MOST juniors and seniors. My bonfires looked more like a teepee than a wedding cake, and topped 100' tall each year. Senior boots didn't become part of the uniform until about 1914 or so. There was no Parson's Cavalry when I was there. And so on and so on.... new things become traditions and old traditions fade away.
The school belongs to those who are students now. I'm sure many from my era will disagree with me, and probably many who are younger than me as well. New Army, Old Army - which is which. Everybody younger than me is New Army, and everybody my age or older is Old Army... at least I've been reminded of that by my elders. My dad was enrolled as Class of 1946 and graduated as Class of '49. He shook his head at some things he called "New Army", but said the same thing to me - "It's your school now".
Gig 'Em!