Any show that includes "What about my ding-a-ling?" as a serious question has to be good.

Ok watched the first 3 seasons, but just watched part of first episode and decided to give up on show. Mistake or not? Can still go On Demand

Season 1 Fantastic
Season 2 Perhaps worse thing seen on tv
Season 3 Meh

I liked Season 2, but it would have been better if there wasn't so much going on. A lot of story arcs were either abandoned or hastily wrapped up.

I agree. Season 2 was fine, but it would have been so much better if they hadn't crammed about 3 seasons worth of plots and arcs into it.

Agree with Clavell on the first 3 seasons. I don't think season 4 has been too bad. The only other shows I've got in the dvr hopper right now are TWD and Homeland, so I have room for a mediocre show.

I'm probably in the minority, but I'm liking this season. It is more coherent than normal, and the storylines are somewhat intertwined. Also, people don't keep coming back from the dead (not yet at least), so that's an improvement over season 3.

Plus, major bonus points for Twisty. I actually wouldn't mind if he came back from the dead and killed the new clown.

Wow, who is worst monster on the show...Dandy or Stanley the Grifter.....


Spoiler.........


































I was afraid they were going to murder and preserve Ma Petite. I am glad they didn't as she is such a sweet and wonderful person. Stanley is a true piece of garbage for wanting to kill a person to sell to that odditorium. As for Dandy he is a psychopath who is being enabled by his weak willed mother. I think he will emerge as the true evil on the show.

I miss Twisty

I think Stanley's "member" will be cutoff by the blonde and sold to the museum of oddities...a couple of episodes back it was implied that he had a freakishly large wang....poetic justice If you will.

This episode was remarkably "meh."

To channel Dot, Dandy was quite boring, and his whiny tantrums are just annoying and make him uninteresting. Go full Gacy already.

Emma Roberts

Agree on the meh. You can't kill twisty and follow it with meh.

Dot is not a nice freak. And that dad is one psycho sob.

This season is becoming very boring.


But

quote:

---

Emma Roberts

---

+1

Love that girl.

The modern musical numbers serve no purpose. I wish they would stop.

quote:

---

The modern musical numbers serve no purpose. I wish they would stop.

---

I've FF'd through every musical number this season. I treat them like I did Dana scenes in last season's Homeland. It's enhanced my enjoyment.

Loved Season One, never got all the way through 2 & 3 and didn't even watch 4.

The season took a dive off the cliff when they killed off Twisty.

It's just not very entertaining. The story lines are boring as hell. They should be doing a lot more with Dandy and his depravity rather than focusing on the freaks in the troupe. It's a total snoozefest.

bump before it off the watchlist...

The show is tightening up and improving. Dandy is fun.

quote:

---

The show is tightening up and improving. Dandy is fun.

---

That's good to hear, unfortunately they screwed the pooch early and no one is watching anymore.

Tonight was quite possibility the dullest hour of TV I've seen. On break until the 7th. Will I watch again? Honestly don't know.

quote:

---

Tonight was quite possibility the dullest hour of TV I've seen.

---

It wasn't scary AT ALL...but I really enjoyed it. It actually had real human emotion. Definitely a first for this show!

I loved how they explained how Pepper was also in the Asylum season.

This episode was just depressing, but I did appreciate the backstory on Pepper. I found it ironic that Elsa was lamenting how people tossed Pepper out because she was such a burden, yet it seemed as though that was exactly what she was doing, although she clearly did not recognize that.

With the visit to Briarcliff, I thought it would have been fun to have Jessica Lange play multiple characters.

I guess it might have been interesting if you watched Season 2. I haven't. Thus extremely dull.

This is the actress who plays Pepper:

quote:

---

Tonight was quite possibility the dullest hour of TV I've seen. On break until the 7th. Will I watch again? Honestly don't know.

---

Pulled up the DVR, read the preview. Yep. Don't care.

I'm hate watching this show at this point. Why can't i just stop?

The holidays helped me end the torture. Deleted from the series manager.

Sticking with it through the season finale next week. So the doc who tortured the hand maker was the nazi doc on season 2 asylum.

RIP Emma Roberts

Season was a disaster.

quote:

---

Season was a disaster.

---

Haven't watched the finale yet, but can't think of anything that could save it. Don't know what they were even trying to do with this season., it was more disorganized than Asylum.

It was bad! I'm giving up on this series.